Canadian tar sand production will not hit 5mmbbl/d.

NRCAN pegs a 'possible' tripling of production to 3mmbbl/d by 2020 but I highly doubt that as water and NatGas usage rates (let alone the fact that we are using gold to make lead) are completely unsustainable.

The GHG impact of the whole affair accounts for 1/3 of total Canadian inputs - 1/3!

Suffice to say there are already calls for a moratorium on expansion by the city, native groups, greens and opposition parties alike.

I think it is a question of time spans.

I agree by 2020 3m b/d is pushing the infrastructure to its limits.  But by 2040 or so, 5m b/d seems very possible.

On the natural gas question, what I have is the data point that 0.8 mcf is needed to produce one barrel of oil from tar sands. (that was in the fact sheet for one of the income trusts).

5m b/d is 1.825bn b/d pa, which is therefore 1.46bn mcf.  I haven't done the reserves comparison (which would have to include the Mackenzie Delta and offshore Arctic Reserves) but this doesn't seem to be impossible.  And there is the possibility of using 'mini nuke' nuclear reactors as steam sources.

Water is tricky, but again not impossible.  1. better recycling of water 2. pipe it from further away.

I suspect carbon sequestration will be used for the later plants, to reduce CO2 emissions.

At some price for oil, the political constraints can be bought off.  As Alberta's population rises, it will get more and more difficult for a Federal Government to ignore that electoral impact, and Alberta itself needs that development and investment.  When the Feds and the Provinces get aligned, things happen (think the reforms to the Canada Pension Plan).

Sir, the only reason for Alberta's increasing population is the tar sands development!  But politicians aren't deep thinkers, so maybe you wll be correct.
Most people moved to Alberta as a result of the oil and gas boom overall... not the tar sands.
"I agree by 2020 3m b/d is pushing the infrastructure to its limits.  But by 2040 or so, 5m b/d seems very possible."

This statement is nonsensical, moreover, you completely hand wave the moratorium calls away.

Meanwhile, the Mackenzie Delta pipeline is already held up by the D'nay nation nor have we covered how said pipeline is going to traverse a tundra of buckling permafrost.