This is the dumbest structure for a bet I've ever seen. It is essentially two bets. One bet is the price of oil and the other is how many barrels a week's pay will buy. Come Jan 1, 2011 both parties could claim victory. The price of oil fails to reach $200 and Tierney claims victory while the amount that a week's paycheck can buy drops and Simmons claims victory.

;}

Absolutely right.

The actual bet was on the price of oil. Tierney just revealed something about what he would have been prepared to bet on, and I chose to illustrate that. Had Matt taken him up on those terms, that (hypothetical) bet would have been looking pretty bad to date.