[blockquote]

For myself, the motivation to share knowledge and ideas on this site and interact with the TOD tribe would lose much of its 'meaning' if I were to become formally compensated.

[/blockquote]

Perhaps, but the money you made working on Wall Street is what enables you to put so much time into your articles thereby allowwing you a place of social prominence in the TOD tribe. If you were working 10 hour days six days a week, my guess is you would be limited to 2-3 short posts per week as a regular member.

I make a living from Latoc (I think everybody knows this already) and can't say it's diminished the meaning at all. If anything, it's made it more meaningfull to me as the money has enabled me to put more energy and time into it. If I was working 10 hour days at a law firm, the site would get updated maybe (at best) once a week.

in general I would say you have a valid point, however I did NOT make piles of money on wall st (or rather, I did make alot, but spent it all in profligate ways). I do have a small warchest, and somehow manage to make more money each year than I spend because I've drastically reduced expenses, but I am not wealthy by any (U.S.)standards.

Perhaps I have a mutation -things like truth and discovery have always been more valuable to me, even in MBA graduate school. Of course, this assumes I have food on table and roof over head and next years food and roof paid for etc.. If I had unlimited funds, I would write much more often here - you are right about that. Oh, that is if I had finished my phd, finished my speeches, planted my garden, read the 30+ books I have sitting here, spent time with friends, exercised, etc. etc. Dunbars number applies to the human cognitive limitations of how many people we can realistically have relationships with, I don't know if theres a name for how many activities a 1400 cubic centimeter brain can physically handle...but whatever the name/number is, I'm close to it. (Schizophrenia to follow...)

Matt- I'm no saint and don't claim to be. If I really wanted to make money doing peak oil/resource depletion research, I'd do it privately with a hedge fund, etc. To me this is more socially rewarding, (except for the BS administrative side...) But its not all a one way street - I have learned tons from the commenters in this community, things that would be difficult to find elsewhere all in one place.

Then again, this all may be my own self-deception, which will be the subject of my next post as it relates to Peak Oil, Climate Change and resource depletion.