Dave,

I make it clear that I know Roger Diwan.  Roger Diwan is a friend of mine.  And Dave, you are no Roger Diwan. ;-)

Seriously, great post.  I want you to know I was only fooled for a moment.  However, you would have made a great panelist, for sure.

Of the four actual participants, I thought Diwan's statements made the most sense all through the discussion.

Would he consider posting here at TOD on his thoughts about peak oil?
I doubt it.  He gets paid a lot of money for his opinions. But I agree with your assessment of Roger.  All the PFC personnel are top notch and usually will tell it like they see it.