By any objective standard, the U.S. today is far richer and has a far higher quality of life than it did in 1970.

I thought only Sith Lords speak in absolutes. By "any" obective standard?

Talk about your freak-o-nomics. Halifn's argument leaves out the HUGE HUGE externality of fossil fuels coming in from foreign sources to save the US economic glutonmaximus. I guess those time machine aliens are going to come to our global rescue the next time around and bring us extra-galactic oil. Right. Well yea..eh..aah. You never know. There's sound logic for you.

As for "far richer":
I don't know if being in debt up to your eyeballs (2 Trillion) makes you "richer".

As for "quality of life", it's a complicated subject:
http://www.rspb.org.uk/birds/sotukb/wildbirdindicator.asp

http://www.flynnresearch.com/indicators_sochealth.pdf

http://www.co-intelligence.org/y2k_upnotup.html

http://www.flynnresearch.com/calvert.htm

I have sympathy for your argument, step back, and hope to find time to properly read the flynnresearch links, they look interesting.

It's quite hard to evaluate USA personal wealth, let alone quality of life, over the last 20 or 30 years, many of the official stats have been so messed with. I have seen credible data that indicates the income of the lower 80% of the US population has declined fairly steadily in constant $ terms since the late 1970s. I think that US per capita wealth in constant $ terms peaked in about 1978.

The truth for more than 50% of the US population is probably: life is worse now than 30 years ago. Despite economic growth, despite the extra consumption of fossil hydrocarbons, despite the extra money bouncing around. I'm not talking relatively (they feel poorer but are actually richer) I am talking in absolute measures of life quality. Is a child richer for watching hours of cartoons on TV or for interacting with a parent?

Later, when we or our descendents look back, I think they'll conclude that somehow we bought a delusion and went off the rails in many ways. It will seem so obvious then, in retrospect. They will find it hard to understand how we couldn't see it.

There are many inaccuracies in Halfin's post. US oil consumption was exponential to 1973, corrected by 20% by 1980 then grew on a linear basis to date and is forecast by the EIA to continue so.