Jay is just very rigorous and disciplined in his analysis.  Arrogance is a emotional subjective measurement that has no bearing on his discussions.  If Jay was much younger he would have the energy and skills to be a peerless data freak of the six-sigma precision level of the vaunted TOD leaders like Stuart, Goose, et al.

If you wish, you can currently join his group to participate in his current poll, and browse the archives.  Just no new postings till he opens the forum again.

I 'lurked' for some time before I finally first posted.  'I have had my ass handed to me a couple of times' by Jay for not being coherent at his level, but that is just 'my phrasing' of me composing a sloppy post [I belatedly deserved his non-emotional rebuke]-- He is generally unfailingly polite, using pure facts to slay incorrect theories.  His 'dry' sense of humor is hilarious too.

Bob Shaw in Phx,AZ  Are Humans Smarter than Yeast?

RE: Ass handing

Perhaps you should have told Jay that he's wrong - we're not running out of energy... we're just running out of oil : )

we're not running out of energy... we're just running out of oil

We will never "run out of oil".
Our straws will just keep making harder and harder sucking sounds as we wind our way down into the gunkier, less liquid, and less concentrated pockets of the stuff.

One other thing we will never run out of is the ability of we humans to delude ourselves. We are so good at this.