so to put it simply your saying that these enhanced recovery techniques are like cutting a bigger hole in a bottle of soda, you can get more out now but at the cost of having less for later? this then has a effect on the whole picture by making the peak closer and higher while giving us a much steeper decline after words?
Makes sense to me, we have had a very long history of short-changing the future for short term gain..
If you want to stick to soda bottle:

You have a bottle of soda.  You can only invest a limited amount of movement into the bottle to empty it.

Do you:

  1. Shake it hard, then open it and capture the gusher
  2. Open it and slowly tilt it sideways

pushing a field too hard means you will strand hydrocarbons.     Somewhere you have to balance the cost of running the extraction equipment VS the resulting gain from the hydrocarbon.