I'd like you to try the no taxes arguement on the IRS when they audit you and report back to us. Gold is not legal tender in the USA, and hasn't been since 1932. How are you going to buy groceries with it when TSHTF? How are you going to get change, a semi full of $20 bills? Whats to prevent the local war lord, or just any thug, from killing you for it after a very long torture session?

As I said, collecting gold is like a crow picking up a bright shiny piece of tin foil.

A small stash of pre-1965 (= pure coin silver) dimes and quarters might be prudent "just in case". Those will work to facilitate trades for food etc. in the case of hyperinflation or other economic catastrophes.

sometimes you can pick up silver dollars and half dollars at not too much of a premium over bullion. these are practically worn out, of very little value to any self respecting collector. i assume if the us experiences hyperinflation, they will still be legal tender of the liquid variety, after all they were minted by the us govt (for what that is worth).

Whats to prevent the local war lord, or just any thug, from killing you for it after a very long torture session?

What's to prevent him from torturing and killing you for your real estate? Your food cache? In other words, it's a purely rhetorical device that serves no purpose in this discussion.

The real value of gold and silver is after a collapse if/when some form of society begins to reassert itself. There will be a medium of exchange and if history is any guide, gold and silver may well be that medium or readily exchangeable for that medium. So no, gold and silver is not for the day after the crash. It is for the day after the day after the crash, if you follow my meaning. ;)

Ghawar Is Dying
The greatest shortcoming of the human race is our inability to understand the exponential function. - Dr. Albert Bartlett

Hehe...Greyzone!

My response would have been...I will be the local warlord!

;-P

Sorry, I don't have any gold for you. You'll have to accept these ephemeral computer blips in tribute:

........................ ←blips

There, that should be enough for now.

The problem will solve itself.
But not in a nice way.

Blips acceptable....now kneel.

;-P

I shall expect more blips tomorrow, same time, or else!

oilmanBob,

You make some valid points. Please consider that after tshtf that we may most likely trend toward a barter economy. "Buying" groceries may be a thing of the past and using a wad of US twenties may be a fair trade for a roll of toilet paper. Solid Gold or Silver, whether bullion or pre 64 dimes and quarters or Aunt Mae's table setting for 12 will still have an intrinsic appear to many.

It may be that the development of currency was an outgrowth of bartering, where the person had something to trade but I did not want what he had. If we found some mutually agreed upon token of value, such as a gold nugget, we could trade that because it was easier to carry and if I went somewhere else I could likely find someone interested in the nugget with something I wanted.

Later Governments got into the act and acted as intermediaries to "Guarantee" the purity of the nugget and to control the action.

Fair point on the warlords and thugs. Recommend considering some personal protection. Better yet, just make sure that you set yourself up as one of the warlords.

Just my '2 cents' worth

EJ

Hello EJ,

I can recommend "The History of Money" by Jack Weatherford, which traces the evolution of money as a concept from barter through commodity money, metals, the invention of coins, banknotes etc. A really interesting read.

Cheers,
xuewen

>You make some valid points. Please consider that after tshtf that we may most likely trend toward a barter economy. "Buying" groceries may be a thing of the past and using a wad of US twenties may be a fair trade for a roll of toilet paper. Solid Gold or Silver, whether bullion or pre 64 dimes and quarters or Aunt Mae's table setting for 12 will still have an intrinsic appear to many.

There is a fatal flaw with hoarding PMs for future currency use after THSHTF or even an the belief of a barter system right after the collapse.

What do you expect to buy with your PM's after the collapse? Most goods are trucked in hundreds or thousands of miles away. Manufacturing plants that crank out Toilet Paper, Toothpaste, etc, are all dependant on a oil-power transportation system to deliver vitual resources (Just in Time) and require that transportation system to deliver them to consumers. What is that you expect that you will find someone selling something that you want or need?

The difference is that in the past most goods that consumers purchased were manufactured locally or used a distribution system to get them to your area. The transportation systems of the past have mostly been dismantled and replaced with vehicles that are 100% dependant on Oil. When THSHTF, its very likely that civilian access to precious Oil and other transportation fuels will be virtually non-existant. This means the distribution system that services you today, would be non-existant in a collapse. Today few people are capable of manufacturing goods and services without advanced equipment that is dependant on reliable electricity or abundant sources of natural gas or oil. Today, Machines make the products we use, and people maintain the machines. The machines are depend on reliably power and ofter premanfactured or process materials that are produced in other factories that are hundreds or even thousands of miles away. For instance virtually all of the fertializers and pesticides used in domestic agraculture are shipped in from overseas near abundant natural gas and other fossil based feedstocks because its no longer economical to produce these products here in North America.

The first few years will be the toughest as virtually everything today is done with machinary. Its going to take a long time for people to learn how to do things the old ways since most of the people knowledgable have passed on. Its going to take even much longer before large distribution systems and manufacturing is restored back to a 19th Century level. Think about the chaos created with the fuel pumps go dry? How many farmers today own draft animals and non-oil powered harvesting equipment? How many farmers purchase seeds with the terminator gene and lack heirloom seeds? How many farmers use natual gas fired grain dryers for long term grain storage? All these factors will make it very unlikely that a barter system will appear overnight to fulfill your needs. Just look what happened to the small area near New Orleans after Katrina. Imagine there were no helicopters and no airlifts, trucks or diesel powered boats bring in supplies. Do you think you would find your PM's very useful?

In my opinion loading up on PM's instead of using time & money to become as much as self sufficient as possible is a poor choice. Remember that the richest man in a desert is a dead man without water. This would apply during a collapse. You'll hoarding a bunch of shiny pieces of metal that look pretty but contribute nothing to your future security and wealthfare in a crisis. Good luck trying to barter for food, energy or any essential resources, when all of your neighbors are struggling to just put enough food on the table to avoid starvation. They certainly are not going to barter for food if they don't have enough for themselves no matter how much PM's you offer them.

In a crash situation, it won't be gold that everyone wants, it will be hand pumps, solar stills, moonshine, and organic tobacco. Having a lot of silver won't mean anything if no-one has enough food.

Having PMs, and lacking the actual resources you need, puts the seller in control. "I want an ounce of gold for 50 lbs of flour." Your hunger will dictate the outcome of this transaction.

If you want to stash away some bullion, also stash away MREs, wood, hand-powered equipment, and weapons.

It is possible to make paper by hand. My wife does it as a craft hobby. If things really got bad, and manufactured paper were totally unavailable, you bet we could go into full-scale production to make paper for barter. I'll bet other people could make a lot of other stuff too if they really had to.

Bob,
Gold, silver, productive farmland, investment grade diamonds among many other things are all options for an individual that wants to protect themselves from inflation.
There have been many times in history when converting currency to the above listed assets has been a smart move. Weimar Germany, 1970's Argentina, 1990's USSR a few.
Gold is convertible into currency in almost every country in the world. What's to prevent a local warlord from taking anything from an indivual or his family?
Different strokes,,if it's not your thing that's cool but gold may protect an individuals savings in the future.
Who knows?

Regards,
Gunga

oilmanbob,

"Gold is not legal tender in the USA, and hasn't been since 1932."

I beg to differ with you.
There are $5 (1/10 oz), $10 (1/4oz), $25 (1/2 oz), and $50 (1 oz)
US mint legal tender (face value amounts) gold coins available (freshly minted).

With gold at $670 an oz it would not be wise to spend them. Any bank will execpt them as legal tender at the "face value" amount.

http://www.monex.com/prods/gold_coins.html

DD