Natural gas prices have been rising faster than oil.

It's not only that. If you map local natural gas availability against use of oil for heat in New England (where most of the oil heating occurs) you'll note that natural gas isn't even an option without a local NG infrastructure build out first. So what's going to happen in short order is this: Once heating oil passes about $5 a gallon (that is, about 40 cents from now) it will be more expensive in New England than passive electric heat (heat pumps not being efficient in New England's cold winters). Those who can least afford the oil will quickly switch to space heaters, not just to save money, but because electricity, unlike oil, is generally billed after you use it, not before.

There are also a lot of wood pellet systems - both stoves and furnaces - being installed in New England. Unfortunately, pellets are in large part a byproduct of lumber production. Lumber production is way down. There will be pellet shortages this winter, driving prices up. And pellet prices historically have risen to near-parity with oil. Regular wood stoves can be fed more cheaply, if you don't count the labor involved even in stacking wood and building the fire.

Still, there will be a large switch to electric heat. That will (1) fry the mains - most of New England is already close to electrical infrastructure capacity even at last year's loads; (2) start fires in badly-wired older houses; (3) cause the utilities to buy more power. As for the last, wholesale electricity prices are largely determined by the price of NG, since nationally many of the newest generators burn that. So this will in that indirect way be a move to NG, pushing its cost up more, pushing electricity's cost up more. If that goes up enough, those of us who can afford it in New England will fire up our oil furnaces again.

What we really need is massive investment in wind, nuclear and electrical infrastructure. Unfortunately there are too many retirees in New England who can't stand the sight of wind mills, and hippies who can't stand the thought of radiation.

Hi, I don't suppose that it will save your grid getting fried, but air heat pumps are now being built which can cope with New England Temperatures.
Here is a Canadian company:
http://www.gotohallowell.com/technical.html
Hallowell International: Technical Data

The Japanese, surprise surprise, are also moving fast on this with pumps using carbon dioxide:
http://www.r744.com/news/news_ida210.php
Coming soon: ITOMIC Eco-cute heat pump - R744.com News

I believe that it may be some time before those are available in the States though.
If you think of getting one the guy to talk to is Here in Halifax - I think he recommends a Fuji model.

Hi Dave,

Just so they don't go moving the international boundary markers on our account, Hallowell is an American company based in Bangor, Maine. And you were close -- Fujitsu is the manufacturer of ductless heat pumps I consider to be among the very best in the industry.

Cheers,
Paul

Darn! You've uncovered our nefarious British Imperialist plot to 'readjust' the boundary!

Dup post

... heat pumps not being efficient in New England's cold winters...

Hi whit,

Can you elaborate on this point for me? I'm curious because I live in an area that is at least as cold if not colder than New England and my heat pump has slashed my heating costs by some 75 per cent.

Cheers,
Paul