The notion that Easter Island died due to the cutting of the trees is only partially correct. According to Jared Diamond, the problem was more subtle than that. Somewhere along the way, the islanders brought rats onto the island and the rats liked to eat the nuts from the main tree species on the island. As a result, the rats eventually grew into a population such that no new trees could grow back, once cut down. Even if the islanders had not cut a single tree, once the rats arrived, the trees were going to disappear as they lived out their life cycles and no young were able grow and replace them. Cutting the trees only sped up the process.

As for Prop 13, I'm one of the casualties as I had applied for a job with the State, meeting all the requirements, and after Prop 13 the hiring freeze killed the job. So much for a shot at a career and a "normal" life. I've experienced mostly unemployment since then...

E. Swanson

That sounds like a convenient escape clause for the Lumberers. I have to wonder if these people weren't also killing off those animals that might have thrived as the predators to the juicy Rat Population.

We have a definite knack for throwing natural systems out of whack. Maybe it's our ability to envision 'un-natural' things. Deforestation also did in the people up on the fertile plains of Mesa Verde, so I've heard.. the soils wore out, water tables evaporated and the erosion capped it all off. And the people left.

Why would there have been predators of rats? It was maybe the most isolated ecosystem on the planet, and a very tiny one at that. There were no rats for any such predators to co-evolve with.