darwinsdog -

Thanks. That's very interesting. One hand washes the other, even down there among lowly roots and fungi.

Accepting it as true the P fertilization inhibits this fungi-mediated P exchange, if you don't continually add an amount of P equal to the amount that is removed when the crop is harvested, won't you eventually deplete the soil of P?

..if you don't continually add an amount of P equal to the amount that is removed when the crop is harvested, won't you eventually deplete the soil of P?

Theoretically, yes. But much of the time P is there in the soil, it's just unavailable in soluble form that plants can use. The idea is that by not inhibiting the mycorrhizae via tillage & P supplementation, they will make P available for plant use.