Stories tagged with "cornucopians"
Cornucopians - A Guide for the Perplexed
Posted by Dave Cohen on September 2, 2006 - 2:14pm
Topic: Sociology/Psychology
Tags: abiotic oil, cornucopians, iea, jerome corsi, julian simon, leonardo maugeri, lindsey grant, paul ehrlich, peter huber, pfc energy, steven levitt, thomas gold, vaclav smil [list all tags]
Part 1 defines Cornucopian Fallacies and gives a mainstream view from PFC Energy by way of contrasting such extreme views with a moderate voice in the center.
Part 2 presents a taxonomy of some present day Cornucopians who believe that there are no limits to growth. Bear in mind that those concerned about peak oil are sometimes labelled with a broad brush as Cassandras predicting eschatological doom. All of us fit somewhere on this scale.
The Doom & Gloomers are on the far left. The Cornucopians are on the far right. I am in the position left of center marked by an X today but that may change tomorrow should circumstances change. I believe we should never lose our sense of humor around here, a crime of which I have been guilty on occasion. Naturally, many serious points are made along the way.
This post does not deal with some optimists in the energy business like Amory Lovins, CERA, Michael Lynch and CGES who deserve a more extended treatment. That will be the subject of another story.
Poll: Where are you in the peak oil taxonomy?
Posted by Super G on May 22, 2006 - 11:54pm
Topic: Sociology/Psychology
Tags: cornucopians, doomers, peak oil, taxonomy, technopeakers, traditionalists, wingpawns [list all tags]
Last week there was a hilarious post that proposed a taxonomy of the camps in the peak oil debate. (Hat tip to several commenters who pointed it out over the past week.) While I don't agree with everything that was said, it's definitely an interesting exercise. Four main species are proposed: Cornucopians, Traditionalists, Technopeakers, and Doomers. WHT joins the fun with a fifth species, Wingpawns.
I was going to paste in descriptions of each species, but I found that quotes were too lengthy and I didn't want to cut out anything. So I encourage you to read the two posts linked above and then take the poll below the fold.


k Nation (Jim Kunstler)






GAIA Host Collective