Stories tagged with george pataki

Hard Look at Gov. Pataki Ethanol Proposal

As expected, Gov. George Pataki's (R-NY) alternative fuel proposal  that I wrote about earlier in the week, is largely based on increasing ethanol production and availability. As I learned from Cornell Professor Pimentel's analysis of corn to ethanol, the Energy Return On Energy Invested (EROEI) is low (perhaps less than 1.0) and cannot be scaled to replace more than a fraction of transportation fuel. But the proposal has stirred earnest debate in New York about the efficacy of investing so much in ethanol with this NY Times article.

Gov. George E. Pataki wants to ... make ethanol and biodiesel, two controversial alternative fuels, available in the 27 service areas on the New York State Thruway and in 100 more stations throughout the state as early as this year, in a first small step toward reducing the state's petroleum consumption. The governor is also proposing incentives to bring refineries that produce ethanol into the state.

So, let's explore ethanol's place in New York's alternative energy basket.  

New York to Move Away from Oil?

In George Pataki's final State of the State address, and perhaps his opening speech of his 2008 presidential bid, he talks about oil dependence:

Let's envision the New York State the next generation will inherit from us - let's consider the limitless potential the future holds for the great State of New York.
[snip]
We don't have to look far for evidence that the time to transition away from foreign oil is now - it is right there on the gas pumps and in our home heating bills.

Not just here in New York, but across the nation, our reliance on foreign oil is hampering the financial freedom of our working families and their employers; it is hurting our economy, damaging our environment and enriching regimes that support, harbor and encourage the terrorists who threaten our national security.

I'm glad that Pataki is raising these issues as not just environmental do-gooding, but integrating financial and security issues. As a state with little fossil fuel reserves, stimulating development of renewables is critical for New York's survival in a peak oil world.

New Yorkers Split on Strike Blame

BROOKLYN BRIDGE, 7:30am As we enter day 3 of the transit strike, it's a good time to reflect on public opinion. NY media coverage has focused mostly on commuter frustrations and heated words between the heads of the MTA, TWU, Governor Pataki and Mayor Bloomberg (who actually has no control over the MTA). If you were to just watch the local Fox News channel, with their "Illegal Strike" graphics, you would think everyone hates the union and there is no public support for the strike. However, according a new Marist Poll, New Yorkers are actually pretty split about who's to blame for the strike with 39% blaming the MTA vs. 40% for the TWU. As you could imagine, due to the many inconveniences, a majority (55%) of New Yorkers are against the strike, but surprisingly 38% of people actually favor the strike. When broken down on ethnic and racial lines, there is a wide divide between support for the strike between New Yorkers who are white (23%), Latino (44%) and African-American (61%).

While no public official gets high approval rating for their handling of the strike, TWU president Roger Touissaint's approval is 39% vs. 27% for Pataki (who really controls the MTA's board). Bloomberg has a 43% approval rating for the strike.

In general I think this shows that there is little love for the MTA and shows that minority groups have higher support for unions taking action.

High Probability of a Strike

Last week, the MTA and the TWU did not reach an agreement on a new contract. Based on some insider reports I have heard, there is a very high probability of a strike this week. The NY Times has done some good coverage of all sides: MTA, Union, Commuter. In particular the article that resonates with why I believe the strike will happen and could get ugly is that George Pataki is running for president and wants to look tough against municipal unions. This coming from the same man who negotiated sweetheart deals to win the endorsement of other powerful unions when he was running for governor.

Again, I really hope there isn't a strike, but if there is I hope people will not only realize the value of mass transit but perhaps find that walking or biking or telecommuting is really not that bad. I also wonder how Bloomberg's mandatory carpooling experiment will work out.