Cyclone Gonu Thread 3 (Last Updated 10pm EDT, 6/6)
Posted by Prof. Goose on June 6, 2007 - 3:00am
Topic: Supply/Production
Tags: bandar abbas, cyclone, cyclone gonu, gas prices, india, iran, mina al fahal, muscat, oil, oil prices, oman, pakistan, peak oil, qalhat, sur, united arab emirates [list all tags]
New thread for Cyclone Gonu as of noon EDT, 6/7 can be found here...please put new material in the comment thread there.
Exclusive--Please credit The Oil Drum and Chuck Watson of KAC/UCF. KAC/UCF and Chuck Watson are forecasting, based on their damage models, that the Qalhat (Sur) LNG terminal will be out for 20-30 days and the Mina al Fahal oil terminal will be down for 10-20 days--all of this assuming they are built to US standards. (NB: These damage estimates have decreased a bit since the last model run...and assume US construction standards.)
All tips and resources (*and there are already many down there in earlier threads, let's replicate that here today in the third thread! Thank you!*) welcome in the comment thread below. If you have any insights, please email the editors box with the word GONU in the subject.
Last updated at 10pm EDT, 6/6. This still could be an important event--but we are in a slow news time right now regarding Oman and the area. If you have any insights, please let us know--email us or put them in the comment thread. We're digging on this too...
Here are links to our first Cyclone Gonu Thread (6/4) and our second thread on the same topic (6/5).
Please put all new resources and insights here as of 1am EDT 6/6, but make sure to check out the first two threads as well.
Why might Cyclone Gonu matter? Well, that answer begins with the fact that the world production of petroleum plateauing around 85 mbbl/day, so any slight blip in supply or exporting could be quite noticeable on the world markets--as a sizeable portion of the world's petroleum exports go through the Gulf of Oman.
Particularly, Oman also matters in this because it produces 743,000 bbl/day; Oman is also a net exporter, non-OPEC, whose production peaked earlier in the decade.
Of course, this storm also has the potential to affect petroleum exports from Iran and the UAE for that matter--mainly because of shipping disruptions in the Straits of Hormuz, but there could also be some real effects on infrastructure and assets depending on storm surge, track and landfall. There are also refining and other production assets in Southern Iran that could be affected depending on the strength of Gonu.
Also, click "there's more" below for more graphics, forecasts, and links, and there's much more from our readers in the comment thread as well...
Resources:
The latest from Margie Kieper at Weather Underground:
Gonu evaporated, essentially, today, while traversing the Gulf of Oman. Clouds over the center dissipated, and convection thinned and dispersed outward. It appears that damage was severe along the extreme southeastern coast that I talked about on Jeff's blog Tuesday. Roads to the area have been washed out, and now that winds have subsided, helicopters will be able to access the area. It will be morning shortly in Oman, and likely this will bring the first news of what has happened in these areas. [...] The TRMM product indicated that about 175mm of rain fell in Mascat the last 24 hours.
This is an unprecedented event. NO CYCLONE has ever entered the Gulf of Oman. And there are no custom 'storm surge' models available for that area. This forecast is based on my experience and subjective analysis of the seabed slope and storm surge interaction with the sea floor. Considering the region has never experienced a hurricane, let alone a strong one it is highly unlikely the loading facilities or platforms were constructed to withstand the forces - both wave action and wind force - that they will experience. Significant, damage will occur. How much long term damage, and the volumes associated with it - can not be determined at this time.
And here's the latest projected track:

As for damage assessments, a tip of the hat to Kinetic Analysis Corporation (affiliated with the University of Central Florida). Early estimates of damage and tracking are available here (Scroll down to Gonu). Here's a graphic:

KAC/UCF has also been kind enough to send us some graphics of the storm surge model with the current forecast:

![]()
Here's a link to a map of land-based oil assets on the peninsula.
Regarding GONU...
http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&ned=&q=gonu
Sorted by date...
http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&ned=&q=gonu&ie=UTF-8&scoring=n
![]()
http://wwwa.accuweather.com/news-blogs.asp?blog=andrews&date=2007-06-04_...
--I can say with confidence that this forecaster has never seen the likes of this
If you go here, and click
on the North Indian Ocean links, you can get a feel for how rare this is. From 1995 on, no tropical storm of any strength ever reached the Persian Gulf.


http://www.lib.utexas.edu/maps/middle_east_and_asia/iran_strait_of_hormu...
(from Stuart: There's past year storm tracks at The University of Hawaii (click on the North Indian years). Here's the most active past year I could find (1998):

http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/cabs/Iran/Background.html
Here's a map of the area:


![]()



Here in SoCal, a couple inches of rain in the San Bernardino mountains will trigger mudslides that wreak of havoc on the cities of San Bernardino and Highland. I believe we have much more vegetation than the mountains of eastern Oman. I can't imagine what is going on over there right now...
Some information on Qalhat LNG near Sur which I overlooked yesterday (this thing will get hit badly). Appears that LNG from there is going mainly to Japan.
"Japanse companies will purchase a total of 23 mtpy of LNG from state-owned Qalhat LNG (SAOC): 700,000 tpy to Itochu Corp. for 20 years starting in 2006, 800,000 tpy to Osaka Gas Co. Ltd. for 17 years from 2009, and 800,000 tpy to Mitsubishi Corp. for 15 years, possibly extending to 20 years."
"The sultanate was expanding its LNG carrier fleet to transport increased production from Oman LNG's projeced third train at its Qalhat liquefaction terminal near Sur on the northeastern coast. Oman's total LNG production was 7.009 bcm (274.5 bcf) in April, up from 6.338 bcm (223.8 bcf) in 2003. Oman will charter a 138,000 cu m LNG carrier to join Sohar and Muscat, the other two carriers in the government's fleet"
Information is from the 2005 World Petroleum Encyclopedia.
I just did a quick search of Japanese news sources for Oman and Typhoon.
Nothing.
Does this mean I'm taking cold showers this winter?
No, Japan imports lots of LNG, this will mean that prices will likely be higher temporarily. Since the port doesn't ship that much LNG it won't have a large impact.
I just found this
Looks like we get only a tiny bit of our gas from Oman. So no big deal to Japan.
It is interesting to note that Japan is by far (58%) the largest importer of LNG in the world at.
Rembrandt -- Your news source cites 2.3mt/y (23 in the quote, but the subtotals add to 2.3) from the Qualhat LNG plant; this represents about 5% of Japanese demand, if I recall correctly.
BTW, this is the setting for the plant:
!
Found it in google earth
http://maps.google.com/maps?f=q&hl=en&q=Qalhat,+Oman&sll=37.0625,-95.677...
Hello Rethin,
Not sure who is correct, but your overhead view and BostonGeologist's photo sure are different.
totoneila,
They are both the same picture; my view just cuts off the southern facility and looks to the southwest. No funny business :)
Hello BostonGeologist & Rethin,
Yep--you are right--once I zoomed out on Rethin's overhead. My apologies to both.
Hello BostonGeologist,
Hell, from the picture: it looks like the whole damn thing is located in a floodplain. Does that mean it is getting hammered on Both Sides from hurricane surge and flashfloods? I bet the Insurance Company is freaking about now!
Bob Shaw in Phx,Az Are Humans Smarter than Yeast?
Not just a flood plain, it looks like an alluvial wash. It is hard to imagine how it will look like once all the water recedes.
"This facility was build to the HIGHEST standards! There is nothing that can destroy it! Praise Allah!"
Ibn Gamblin Al Day
President, Qualhat Construction Corp.
Room #777
Casino Grande, Macao
(no calls please)
All of my hot water heaters (the small wall units) when I lived in Japan used propane gas (well, LPG which I assumed was usually propane). Are you sure your hot water heater uses NG/methane?
Nevertheless, this event demonstrates again how vulnerable Japan is, given that it imports nearly all of its energy sources, with a great share coming from the ME. Anything that happens in the ME thus is of interest to the Japanese, which explains why during Abe's recent tour of that area he was accompanied by a small army of Japanese corp. executives, a first.
I'm pretty sure its LNG. I'll have to check my gas bill when I get home now.
But I see a lot of houses with LPG cylinders outside them as well.
Could someone repost the map that shows where the LNG and Crude oil export terminals are. From the Bloomberg artical mentioned below, Mina Al Fihal seems to pump all of Oman's oil. Seems significant if it is out for 20 days.
Here's the Omani electrical infrastucture from earlier:
Efforting the other one. Where did it go?
Google maps?
MINA AL FAHL
http://maps.google.com/maps?f=q&hl=en&q=23.65,+58.5&ie=UTF8&t=h&om=1&ll=...
QALHAT
http://maps.google.com/maps?f=q&hl=en&q=22.68,+59.4&ie=UTF8&t=h&om=1&ll=...
I would think that the reality of situations such as this in an energy system with little or no slack for shortages would be a wake up call for immediate worldwide Peak Oil preparations.
Oil = money = power. Are we willing to go over the brink before governments start preparing their citizens to live in a world with much less than what they have been accustomed to?
Could this storm be the catalyst that makes the global community have that hard family talk everyone has been avoiding?
That further energy growth with the existing infrastructure is not possible?
www.lawnstogardens.com
New thread on Gonu as of Noon EDT, 6/7.
http://www.theoildrum.com/node/2639
please put all new material and insight there.
Check here for pictures of what Cyclone George did to the north-west of Western Australia 2 months ago- see the bottom pictures of mining camp huts (designed to withstand such winds) absolutely smashed:
http://www.abc.net.au/northwestwa/stories/s1868490.htm
Cross your fingers for oil workers in Oman and Iran.
This rainfall forecast map for THURSDAY from BBC world weather shows a relatively small area of heavy rainfall to the NE of the Oman mountains, centred on the Gulf of Oman. This area is to the N and E of main Omani oil and gas infrastructure (I think). The main hazzard IMO will be from flash flooding in wadis - that can appear hundreds of miles away from where the rain falls.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/weather/world/middle_east/rain.shtml#no_url
This link to the UK MET office world weather allows you to run a short time lapse sequence - showing Gonu in the Gulf of Oman.
http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/satpics/africa_IR.html
And the latest weather from Musat International Airport from Wunderground:
77 °F / 25 °C
Light Rain
Humidity: 96%
Dew Point: 76 °F / 24 °C
Wind: 20 mph / 32 km/h / from the North
Wind Gust: -
Pressure: 29.48 in / 998 hPa
Visibility: 1.0 miles / 1.0 kilometers
UV: 3 out of 16
Clouds: Scattered Clouds 787 ft / 240 m
Mostly Cloudy 2461 ft / 750 m
Few 2953 ft / 900 m
Overcast 7874 ft / 2400 m
(Above Ground Level)
http://www.wunderground.com/global/stations/41256.html
Light rain and 20 mph winds (gusting 30 mph).
73 °F / 23 °C
Heavy Thunderstorms and Rain
Humidity: 100%
Dew Point: 73 °F / 23 °C
Wind: 30 mph / 48 km/h / from the West
Wind Gust: -
Pressure: 29.34 in / 993 hPa
Visibility: 2.0 miles / 3.0 kilometers
UV: 1 out of 16
Clouds: Scattered Clouds 787 ft / 240 m
Mostly Cloudy 2461 ft / 750 m
Few 2953 ft / 900 m
Overcast 7874 ft / 2400 m
(Above Ground Level)
Heavy thuderstorms and 30 mph winds - time to pack away the windsurfer
Note wind from the west suggesting the storm centre is likely to be due north. Also 100% humidity.
Point your left arm directly into the wind and extend your right arm at 90 degrees or right angle and the right arm is pointing at the storm center. Old sailors never forget. In the northern Lat. For southern Lat use the right arm for wind.
Thursday morning
Seeb, International Airport, Oman
Elevation: 26 ft / 8 m
85 °F / 29 °C
Partly Cloudy
Humidity: 52%
Dew Point: 70 °F / 21 °C
Wind: 25 mph / 41 km/h / from the West
Wind Gust: -
Pressure: 29.54 in / 1000 hPa
Visibility: 6.0 miles / 10.0 kilometers
Clouds: Few 1181 ft / 360 m
Scattered Clouds 2461 ft / 750 m
Mostly Cloudy 9843 ft / 3000 m
(Above Ground Level)
Partly cloudy, wind 25 mph - it looks like Gonu has moved on
Some may be interested to know that Cyclonic storms are not uncommon in Oman. Kyle circulated a report on Omani flood preparations that mentioned earlier cyclones in 2002, 1996, 1983, 1977, 1966, 1963, 1959 and 1948.
Following up on my flooding comments in Gonu thread #2, a quote from the wunderground forum:
"still have power in qurum. wind speed continues to pick up - say F5. hear that road through wadi adai (major road out of muscat to quriyat - 90kms SE muscat) has been washed away in 2 locations. that road was only re-constructed 4 years ago and as afar as i can recall culverts and bridges were designed on basis of 50-year storm return period. but remains to be seen whether reports are true"
If reports are true, and they're exceeding 50-year flow in multiple locations this early in the storm curve, it's not good.
I finally found some good material to help evalutate the flood potential:
Hydrology of Wadi Systems: Chapters 1 & 2
Chapter 3
Chapter 4
Chapter 5
Still looking for the later chapters, but items of note from the material above:
-Available rainfall records on the Arabian peninsula reflect only spotty heavy rains; there aren't any large-area, heavy rainfall events examined, so the current event lies outside of the understanding of Oman hydrology
-It takes at least 10hrs of full flow to saturate the banks of wabis in some study areas; before this time a significant amount of the flow transmits below the surface
-Northern Oman has a large alluvial aquifer system which is used heavily for drinking water. An exceptional event like this will be a significant recharge event for that aquifer; this will likely delay the heaviest flow in wabis overlying deep alluvium.
A bit more about the coastal geology/geography; this is all going off what I can see in Google Earth / panoramia, so take w/ a grain of salt, but what I can see is three types of coastline:
Fjordlike/rugged, where the coastal range is innundated and there's no exposure of the continental shelf and no modern alluvial deposits:
Bandar Khairan
Continental shelf exposed w/ modern overburden; these areas are carbonate/limestone bedrock (I assume formed recently in the present gulf of oman) overlaid by pretty classic high-energy alluvium:
Sinkhole in Oman; 5km ssw of Dibab
I love that photo... you can very clearly see the limestone/shallow sea deposits making up most of the wall of the sinkhole, and then the very poorly sorted (wide range of particle size) fluvial (river) deposits lying on top, forming the top several meters of the subsurface. If you look closely, you can see that the larger rocks/boulders in the fluvial deposits are less rounded than the smaller rocks, indicating that they spent little time in the paleo wadi channel upstream and likely made most of their journey from outcropping to coastal plain in just a few flood events.
Anyway, to see the larger setting of this sort of coast:
Dibab, Oman
You can see that the mountains come to a smooth, sharp drop, and that the land sticking out from there extends a distance from the mountains uncorrelated with modern wabi/river paths. This is the outline of the part of the former seabed that has been lifted (or exposed by dropping sealevel). If you look closely, you can see the pattern of modern alluvium deposited on this shelf by later river action.
Lastly is active delta/fluvial dominated coast. Now, in these seas it doesn't take much to be fluvialy dominated (the wave/wind action is normally very subdued, and there's almost no tidal action to speak of), so even a wabi's intermittant flow can maintain an active delta:
Delta in NE Oman
Each of these three coastal types will exhibit a very different response to rainfall, surge, and wave... due to differences in coastal steepness, offshore landform, infiltration, existing drainage pattern, and wave action damping capacity. The modern active deltas are the lowest lying land, but have some vegetation and a greater area of existing drainage channels. The limestone platforms have generally higher land, but smaller channel capacity and reduced infiltration capacity. The rugged coastline rises quickly enough to avoid most surge/wave danger, and offers well-contained drainage, but is largely unpopulated.
This is one of the reasons I love this site - there's such breadth and depth of knowledge. Small point here: the last two links (Dibab, delta) both point to the Dibab image.
The "Sleepless in Muscat" Blog has been updated this morning:
http://sleeplessinmuscat.blogspot.com/
rainsong posted a great real time(ish) GIF yesterday:
http://cimss.ssec.wisc.edu/tropic/real-time/indian/storm/dvor-nh02A.GIF
anyone know how to post this?
Found this one:
http://www.rttnews.com/FOREX/gblnews.asp?date=06/06/2007&item=8
Shipping was yet continuing through the strait yesterday according to this report. The national holiday until Saturday might keep Oman's oil & LNG loading offline for a bit. There was some spare OPEC capacity probable as several OPEC nations have been trending towards expanded production capacity: Iran, Nigeria, UAE, Angola, Algeria, Libya; at least by the EIA charts that is. Indonesia reversed its declines to produce a more or less a stable level of production. World demand has outpaced supply resulting in price increases over the past few years. There were occasional complaints by oil company managements about how difficult it is becoming to find oil reserves. The push to develop heavy oil is underway. With 100's of billions of barrels of heavy oil in place, the decline of conventional oil reserves brings the implementation of heavy oil/tar sands. Unconventional oil is expected to peak later than conventional oil.
From the Above picture it appears the Western Eye Wall is right over the Oil Terminal at Mina al Fahal. Direct Hit.
http://maps.google.com/maps?f=q&hl=en&q=23.65,+58.5&ie=UTF8&ll=23.631865...
This storm has stopped moving. It's been sitting there pounding Muscat and the oil terminal at Mina al Fahal for a couple hours.
What is a bit interesting was his link to the airport - the only airline with real experience of such weather is Air India, and they have cancelled their flights today.
Everyone else seems to think that a weakened hurricane just isn't a big deal.
We'll see.
Hope Sleepless in Muscat is OK, Muscat is currently taking a Direct Hit.
He just put out another update (8th) and things do not seem all that bad in Muscat. He obviously has power.
The Eye has reformed. Storm appears to be strengthening.
http://www.krqe.com/expanded.asp?ID=21755
CNN this morning: "Cyclone Gonu Disrupts Mid-East Oil"
Oil is up sharply in Europe, less so here in the U.S.
So why is this web site showing prices down worldwide?
http://www.upstreamonline.com/market_data/?id=markets_crude
Haven't you been listening to the Propag ...er News. This is no big deal. Concerns have eased and oil shipments are still moving through the strait. Loading will resume at Mina al Fahal within hours. The've told the world this crap, that makes it true, right?
My WTI positions are down now, maybe Tapis or Brent is different.