DrumBeat: February 4, 2008


GeoTimes: Oil Around the World

● Norway Looks North for Oil and Gas

● Oil and Politics in Iraq

● Squabbles over the South China Sea

● Putting India on the World’s Petroleum Map

● Oil Rushes Back to Libya

Kunstler: Serial Bubbles?

Eric Janszen of iTuilip.com has made a splash in the mainstream media with his Harper's Magazine cover story on the "The Next Bubble." His thesis is that a new tidal wave of investment will shortly roll toward "infrastructure and alternative energy." By this Janszen means a revived nuclear power push, refurbishing highways, bridges, and tunnels, "high-speed rail," solar and wind power, and alternative liquid fuels. This coming boom, he says, would be driven by political fear about energy security.

On the face of it, Janszen's proposition seems more promising and intelligent than the previous engineered boom in suburban houses. But it raises a lot of questions and flags.


Oil Rises After Turkish Planes Attack Suspected Kurdish Bases

(Bloomberg) -- Crude oil rose after Turkish planes attacked suspected Kurdish insurgent bases and the Houston Ship Channel reopened following an 18-hour shutdown for fog.


US Crude Outlook-Refinery restarts seen supportive

NEW YORK (Reuters) - The restart of major units at two large Gulf Coast refineries should help offset some of the recent weakness in crude oil demand on U.S. cash crude markets this week, traders and brokers said Monday.

The Shell/Pemex 334,000 barrels per day Deer Park, Texas refinery began restarting units including the fluid catalytic cracker after a major turnaround on Sunday, according to a filing with Texas regulators.


United to charge fliers checking 2 bags

The charge will generate more than $100 million in revenue and cost savings each year, the UAL Corp. carrier said. The change takes effect with travel starting on May 5 and applies to tickets purchased on or after Monday.

Investors have urged airlines to pass on the higher costs of fuel onto passengers through ticket-price increases or similar surcharges.


France, Japan, US cooperate on nuclear reactors

France, Japan and the United States agreed Friday to cooperate in making prototypes of so-called "4th generation" nuclear reactors, according to statements released by each country's energy ministries.

These sodium-cooled reactors, which would not come on line until mid-century, produce more energy per unit of fuel than nuclear reactors currently in operation.

But early prototypes have been plagued with problems. The liquid sodium cooling agent is highly volatile, bursting into flames if it comes into contact with air, and exploding if it comes into contact with water.


'Green collar' jobs seen as prosperous

By 2030, nearly a half-million new jobs could be created in green industries.


Enbridge to lead carbon dioxide storage project

CALGARY — — Enbridge Inc., Canada's largest oil and natural gas pipeline company will lead a group of 19 energy industry participants in the Alberta saline aquifer project, or ASAP.

Under the project, the first of its kind in Canada, participants will seek, design and expand sites to store carbon dioxide in deep saline aquifers.


OPEC accelerating plans to increase oil production

LONDON (Thomson Financial) - OPEC is attempting to speed up plans to bring more oil production to market due to rapidly rising demand from China and India, according to experts gathered at international think tank Chatham House for a conference on Middle East energy supplies.

"OPEC plans to increase output by 3 mln bpd by 2012. They are accelerating their plans to cope with rising demand and to provide a spare capacity cushion for the market," one speaker said.

Earlier at the conference, speakers warned that oil prices will rocket should rising demand and shrinking oil fields lead to a shortfall in supplies.

They underlined that global crude demand is set to soar on the back of Chinese and Indian economic development.


Analysis: Putin to head Gazprom?

WASHINGTON (UPI) -- As the world's attention increasingly focuses on Russia's March 2 presidential election, speculation is rising about what President Vladimir Putin will do in the aftermath.

While it's a foregone conclusion in Russia that First Vice Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev will most likely replace Putin, various theories have been floated, several of which seem to have Putin's support -- that he would take the post of prime minister under a Medvedev presidency, or continue discreetly to exercise power behind the scenes. Now the newspaper Pravda has put forth an intriguing scenario -- that Putin would replace Medvedev as chairman of the board of directors of Russia's natural gas giant Gazprom.


Ukraine makes first step to eliminate Russian natural gas middlemen

KIEV, Ukraine: The Ukrainian government on Saturday announced its first formal step toward eliminating a partly Russian-owned intermediary company from its natural gas purchase deals.

Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko said the country's National Security and Defense Council on Friday instructed the government to break up the contracts between the Ukrainian natural gas distribution monopoly Naftogaz and the Swiss-based trading company RosUkrEnergo because "they contain elements of corruption and are unprofitable."


China needs to cut energy reliance on coal - official

BEIJING (Reuters) - Power and coal shortages in China should serve as a wake-up call for the country to increase power production from nuclear and wind plants, and reduce its reliance on coal-fired generators, a leading energy official said.


Asia coal prices at record high

Coal prices at Australia's Newcastle port, a benchmark for Asian coal prices, jumped to a fresh record of more than $US115 a tonne ($127.25), as a global supply crunch worsened after a series of supply disruptions in key coal exporting nations.


Let us make billions or the lights will go out, warns energy industry

THE trade body for the energy industry says recent allegations of profiteering are a "fallacy" and warned that the alternative to price rises would be power cuts.


Bangladesh: Govt mulling gas import from Myanmar

Chief adviser's Special Assistant Dr M Tamim yesterday said the government is considering importing gas from Myanmar even if it might require sharing fertiliser with that country.


Japan, China study splitting gas profits

TOKYO (Reuters) - Japan and China are considering splitting profits from gas fields in disputed waters in the East China Sea, a Japanese daily reported on Monday, as the two sides race to resolve a row over resources ahead of a visit by Chinese President Hu Jintao in the spring.


Fire Shuts Down Norwegian Oil Platform

OSLO, Norway - A gas turbine fire shut down production from the 20,000 barrel per day Norwegian offshore oil field Njord A on Monday, without causing injury to the platform's 91 crew, the StatoilHydro ASA oil company said.


Rebels claim Nigerian oil delta attack

LAGOS (Reuters) - A prominent Nigerian militant group said on Monday it carried out an armed raid on a navy outpost protecting an oil pipeline hub which killed three soldiers on Saturday.


Zimbabwe: 'Mother of All Poor Seasons' Forecast

Their projection: the harvest may only amount to 30 percent of the total national maize requirements.

The experts blame the crisis on poor agricultural planning by the government and the excessive rains which have been falling since last December.

Most farmers failed to plant on time because they could not access seed, fertilizer and fuel, among other vital inputs.


Kenya: Acute Fuel Shortage Persists in Western Region

Fuel consumers in western Kenya are to continue paying dearly following prolonged disruptions of supply as the region grapples with an acute shortage of the commodity in the wake of political turmoil.

Triton Petroleum company which operates eight retail stations in Eldoret, Nakuru and Kisumu had all its premises affected by the post election violence and loss estimated at 60 per cent.


Armed escort to secure fuel supply

Kenya Shell, a major oil industry player, has discounted fears that fuel supply to the neighbouring landlocked countries of Uganda, Rwanda, Burundi and the Democratic Republic of Congo will be permanently affected by last week’s resurgence of violence in parts of the country.

The firm’s brand and communications manager, Ngaari Mwaura, said the government’s move to provide free security escorts to trucks transporting fuel to Uganda helped ensure oil supply was not badly disrupted.


Shell Says No Damage to Nigeria Pipeline After Attack

(Bloomberg) -- Royal Dutch Shell Plc's Nigerian venture said a pipeline manifold was undamaged and no production was affected following a gun battle in which three naval personnel were killed.


Dutch Gas Guzzler Tax Hammers Exclusive Cars

AMSTERDAM - Buying a Hummer just became 19,000 euros (US$28,000) more expensive in the Netherlands.

A new "guzzle tax" came into force on Friday, penalising cars that exceed a limit on emissions of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide as the Netherlands seeks to reduce its contribution to global warming.


Australian Annual Inflation Gauge Jumps 3.9%, TD Says

Surging fuel costs and soaring home rents drove a pickup in inflation that may prompt Reserve Bank Governor Glenn Stevens to add to last year's two interest-rate increases. Price pressures are building as China's demand for Australian commodities prompts miners to hire workers, worsening a skills shortage that is stoking wages and consumer spending.


Pakistan: CNG crisis

Long queues of vehicles can be seen at the CNG stations throughout the country with vehicles returning back without fuel. The closure of the Sui purification plant following a rocket attack has been cited as the reason for the gas shortage and low pressure. Over 700 CNG stations in the country have been affected by the gas shortage along with domestic consumers, factories and power plants. The situation has resulted in a blame game with the distribution companies questioning the reason of connecting the CNG stations to the domestic network. All Pakistan CNG Association has threatened to observe a countrywide strike against the suspension of gas supply to the CNG stations. About 400 CNG stations have been closed down due to low gas pressure in Punjab and the NWFP.


Pakistan: Many industrial units on the verge of closure due to severe energy crisis

"We desire uninterrupted power supply for sufficient time to ensure completion of most production processes and adherence of the load shedding schedule control on unscheduled break downs", he said. He was of the view that the government should launch a campaign in the media to give true picture of the electricity situation to the masses so that undue usage of power could be controlled. He said severe energy crisis was beginning to take its toll as hundreds of industrial units have so far closed their production and many more are on the verge of closure. He called for measures to control line losses and improve the efficiency of the system.


‘Dean of Oil Analysts’ Maxwell: Oil Shortages Start in 2010; Peak Oil Hits 2012-2015

It all boils down to this, Maxwell told EnergyTechStocks.com: We live in a world where there is only about 1.2% more oil available each year, not enough to keep up with 1.5% annual demand growth. Between now and 2010, this supply shortfall will be made up through a drawdown in inventories, helped out by a slowdown in demand in 2008 and 2009 due to a recession or near-recession in the U.S.

But in 2010, Maxwell said, the shortfall will become greater than can be made up by what’s still in inventory, and thus will begin a long period of global oil scarcity that will get worse starting in 2012 or 2013, which is when Maxwell foresees a “peak” in conventional oil production. It gets even worse in 2015, which is when he expects a peak in the production of all liquids, a category that includes condensates, tar sands oil and biodiesel.


Latin American energy crisis

Strange things happen in the world of Latin American energy. In Argentina, the government decrees clocks must be put forward to counter the threat of blackouts. In Ecuador, where oil output is dropping, the government demands compensation from foreigners in return for protecting the environment by not drilling for oil.

The result is a developing regional crisis. In Argentina, price controls aimed at curbing inflation have boosted energy consumption while discouraging investment. In a recent analysis, Eurasia Group, a risk consultancy, highlighted the role of Latin American citizens’ apparently low tolerance of inflation, but high tolerance for state intervention. That encourages populist politicians to court favour in the short-term with price controls and, given high global energy prices, resource nationalism. No wonder Repsol of Spain is selling off bits of its ill-fated investment in YPF, Argentina’s domestic energy giant, to local buyers. Better regional political connections might help lift some price caps.


ICBC Deposes Citigroup as Chinese Banks Rule in New World Order

(Bloomberg) -- There's a new world order for banks, and the Chinese, for the first time, are the biggest, with a market capitalization that has made perennial No. 1 Citigroup Inc. a distant also-ran behind Industrial & Commercial Bank of China Ltd., China Construction Bank Corp. and Bank of China Ltd.

``The tables have been completely turned,'' said Daniel Yergin, the Washington, D.C.-based chairman of Cambridge Energy Research Associates Inc. during an interview at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland.


Uranium prices seen "choppy" on low output

CAPE TOWN (Reuters) - Spot uranium prices are likely to remain choppy in the face of "anaemic" production and will remain so for the near term, the head of a consulting firm that publishes uranium prices said on Monday.

Kazakhstan has so far been the strongest producer of the silvery white metal used as the basic fuel for nuclear power, but current world production is estimated to last about 3 to 5 years, leaving a potentially big gap in the market.


'Shocking' report finds radioactive vegetables

The newspaper said tests on asparagus, oats and onions produced in the Gerhard Minne wetlands showed that the level of radioactive substances was three times higher than the safe permissible level for human consumption.

Pointing out that intensive gold mining takes place in the area -- and that uranium as a by-product is found in mine dumps there -- the news report said large tracts of land in the area of the Wonderfonteinspruit were 150 times more radioactive than the permitted level.


Investment Guru Jim Rogers: U.S. Economy ‘Pretty Terrifying,’ But It’s Not End of the World

Still, Rogers made a point of saying he doesn’t think this is the end of the world. There should be pockets of prosperity in the U.S. even during the hard times, he said, adding that farmers in Iowa and oilmen in Oklahoma likely will fare well. While the owner of a lake house in Massachusetts will be hurting, he added, the owner of a lake house in Iowa won’t be.


Eco-Heat in Vermont Schools

It's a cold winter's day in the University of Vermont's Jericho research forest, but the discussion amongst the group there is heating up over how trees are being used to heat schools across the state. More than 30 Vermont schools are relying on wood chips as their primary heating source. Wood chip heating systems saved Vermont taxpayers an estimated $760,000 in energy costs during the 2005-2006 heating season.


What communities need to do to survive climate change

Many scientists agree that we have waited too late to address climate change and are now going to suffer some consequences. What is debatable is how severe those consequences will be.


Russian economy succumbs to the oil curse

This is the curse of commodity wealth, the "Dutch Disease" that eats at the competitive foundations of an economy and incubates a parasite culture. No doubt Russia's scientists, engineers, and cyber talent, will enrich the country, but first it must overcome the toxic effects of oil at $90 a barrel.

"We can no longer afford to buy Russian equipment," said Yevgeny Ivanov, head of Polyus Gold.

"The prices here are one and a half times higher than abroad so we're having to break our rigid rule and turn to foreign-made machinery. It is bad news for Russian firms. The commodity super-cycle is catching up with us through higher prices. It is a disheartening picture," he said.


Do high commodity prices speak for themselves?

Stunning new highs in some world commodity prices have catastrophists of all types tapping out SOS in their sleep.

There was, of course, the rise of oil which started 2007 at $50 a barrel and rose above $100 on the first trading day of this year, an all-time high. Wheat which began 2007 at around $5 a bushel reached $10, another all-time high, before retreating slightly. Soybeans which started last year around $6.50 a bushel ended the year above $12 and went on to set an all-time high last month just above $13. And, gold, that quintessential barometer of fear, rose from about $640 an ounce to above $900 recently, shattering its old highs.


UK: Price of food soars to all-time record high

FAMILIES already struggling to make ends meet are being hit by soaring food prices.

Figures yesterday revealed that costs have rocketed by 12 per cent in the last year alone, with the nation’s weekly shopping bill £15 higher than two years ago.


So That's Why Those Bottles Are There...

Thousands of plastic water bottles - approximately 600 pounds worth - sat in Alumni Mall Thursday giving observers a sip of reality: These bottles represent less than a week's worth of LMU's bottled water consumption. And this doesn't even account for bottles thrown into regular trash bins.


Keep consuming!

What’s most fascinating is the mistaken assumption that the developing world is righteously indignant about America’s unimpeachable lifestyle. The reality is that most global citizens want to be like Americans, with all the luxury, excess and environmental impacts that go with it.


A modest proposal

Instead of listening to this doom-and-gloom nonsense, I propose that we stay the course, that we continue on with the way of life we have cultivated and justly deserve thanks to our unique ability as humans to extensively impact the environment and ecosystems around us. If we have the ability to shape the earth's outputs to our needs, why waste time preserving what "used to be"? Nostalgia for the good old days does not translate to sound survival strategies.


Huntington Beach Mayor makes a run for congress

Cook is a member of the board of directors of the Association for the Study of Peak Oil and Gas and serves as Chair of the Energy and Environment Committee for the Southern California Association of Governments.


Drillers eye huge Appalachian gas field

STATE COLLEGE, Pa. - More than a mile beneath an area of Appalachia covering parts of four states lies a mostly untapped reservoir of natural gas that could swell U.S. reserves.

Geologists and energy companies have known for decades about the gas in the Marcellus Shale, but only recently have figured out a possible — though expensive — way to extract it from the thick black rock about 6,000 feet underground.


Raymond J. Learsy: Exxon Rakes in Record $10 Billion Quarterly Earnings While Cheering OPEC's Readiness to Cut Production

The Exxon earnings are not only obscene they are an outrage in that these are not profits that are earned in a competitive marketplace but simply by tailgating OPEC's manipulation. Exxon barely lifted a finger to earn its additional billions other than go along with prices that were the result of collusion by a cartel, and hardly a reflection of a free and unfettered international marketplace. The oil industry apologists are already lining up. To quote one of the spokesmen for the chief peak oil prankster, and cheerleader for ever higher oil prices, Matt Simmons, "A lot of these larger companies are challenged to grow production. That's one of the reasons that oil prices aren't necessarily expensive at $90 a barrel..." Much like Willy Sutton saying he has to hold up another bank because he needs a new getaway car.


OPEC will consider all options at March meeting

LONDON (Thomson Financial) - Qatari Oil Minister Abdullah bin Hamad al Attiyah said that all options were open for OPEC's meeting in March, despite some ministers hinting at cutting or increasing oil output.


Ryanair warns of profits 'storm'

Ryanair has warned that its profits could be halved this year as fuel costs rise and as the UK pound weakens.

The warning came as the budget airline reported that net profit dropped 27% to 35m euros ($52m; £26m) during the October to December quarter.

The drop was its first quarterly decline in a more than a year.

Chief executive Michael O'Leary said that the weakening profits were part of a cyclical downturn in the industry and a "perfect storm" may be lying ahead.


Oil expo thrives amid weakening economy

HOUSTON - Recession? What recession? When thousands of wheeler-dealers gather downtown this week to buy, sell and trade oil and gas projects, they'll be ready to shell out millions of dollars, perhaps tens of millions.


10,000-car backup as ice shuts Chinese road

BEIJING - Railway service inched back to normal Sunday in southern China, a day after one person died in a stampede by frustrated train passengers who were stranded for days because of snow ahead of an important holiday.

More than 10,000 vehicles were backed up on an icy section of a highway in central China's Hunan province, the official Xinhua News Agency said. The vehicles were backed up for nearly 45 miles, even though workers were removing ice from the roads Sunday, it said.


Kuwait to upgrade vital energy sector

The Gulf state of Kuwait plans to spend 51 billion dollars over the next five years to upgrade its vital energy sector which generates 95 percent of its revenue, a top oil executive said Monday.


Gazprom's Oil Unit Plans to Double Output, Invest $70 Billion

(Bloomberg) -- OAO Gazprom Neft, the Siberian oil company once owned by billionaire Roman Abramovich, plans to double crude production by the end of next decade through developing Arctic fields and investing $70 billion.

The oil unit of natural-gas producer OAO Gazprom wants to pump as much as 90 million metric tons by 2020, Chief Executive Officer Alexander Dyukov said in an interview published in the Moscow-based Kommersant newspaper today. His spokeswoman, Natalya Vyalkina, confirmed his comments to Bloomberg News.


CSIRO-Monash Uni biofuel method allays green concerns

AUSTRALIAN scientists say they have developed a greenhouse-friendly way of turning green waste into fuel.

The Furafuel bio-crude oil process, developed by CSIRO and Monash University, can be used to produce petrol and diesel from forest thinnings, crop residues and waste paper, most of which are normally dumped in landfill or burned.


UK's first emissions zone begins

The most heavily polluting lorries are facing charges of £200 per day to enter Greater London as Britain's first low emission zone (LEZ) comes into force.

The £49m scheme uses cameras to check all lorries over 12-tonnes entering the zone against a database of vehicles certified as meeting EU exhaust limits.

Firms whose vehicles are not on the database will be told to pay up.

Raymond J. Learsy:

To quote one of the spokesmen for the chief peak oil prankster, and cheerleader for ever higher oil prices, Matt Simmons . . .

Of course, Learsy and ExxonMobil are--by denying the reality of Peak Oil--in effect encouraging Americans to continue driving SUV's to and from suburban mortgages, in effect, encouraging greater consumption. They are not alone.

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/opinion/viewpoints/vitind...
Dallas Morning News OpEd: Katherine Stout: More roads, not rail

Public transit backers failed last Tuesday to gain corporate support for legislation that would increase sales taxes for expanded public transit – otherwise understood to be an "ambitious" regional rail network. . .

. . . Keeping Texas moving is a high priority, and the inescapable fact is that Texas needs more roads, not more rail cars.

Mary Katherine Stout is vice president for policy at the Texas Public Policy Foundation, a nonprofit, free-market research institute based in Austin.

GM, drugs, religion, evolution, PO, AGW, Pop Overshoot.

You can find everyone's politics and more than you want to know, by
ID'ing their positions on the above.

And absolutely ZERO of the above will be talked about in political discourse.

Raymond J. Learsy:

I think Learsy is an idiot, but I do agree with him that XOM is riding OPEC's coattails. OPEC, Chavez, and Big Oil make strange bedfellows. There is no love lost between the former 2 and the latter, but any moves that restrict supply - intentional or not - benefit Big Oil as well by driving prices higher.

And XOM stockholders has been squished under OPECs boot many times as well.

Where was Learsy then??

FF

Dunno if this is the right place to post this, and it may be old news anyway, but this article on coal use in China caught my eye:
http://www.ecoworld.com/home/articles2.cfm?tid=450

There is a suggestion there that part of the melt of arctic ice is caused by soot from China's coal burn, which as I understand is rather greater than most models of GW suggest.

Let's hope mdsolars ideas of greatly increased PV in China come to pass!

Quote from the above article:

Meanwhile coal production in China increases at an astonishing pace, and most of the operating coal plants in China lack modern scrubbers to remove gross air pollution. In this regard, concerns over CO2 may be misplaced. It could be that black soot that settles on arctic ice is warming the northern polar regions more than the CO2 that accompanies that soot. And the ill-health attendant to that soot is beyond debate. The costs to remove genuine pollution, nitrogen dioxide, sulpher dioxide, carbon monoxide, particulate matter and toxic metals - is far, far less costly than attempting to sequester the CO2 emissions. And the technology to do this is well established.

No scrubbers! No wonder they have trouble with pollution. I can see how far off carbon sequestration is!

http://www.poweronline.com/content/news/article.asp?docid=cc4d249e-9a58-...

Correct me if I am wrong in my thinking, but using an average of 270,000,000 barrels per month from EIA finished motor gasoline report works out to 136,080*10^6 gallons per year. Divide this by 4,000 gallons/acre/year production by an algae farm equals 34,020,000 acres or a land mass about the size of Iowa at 36,013,440 acres or 56,271 sq miles. Doesn't seem like that large of an area, once spread out over the nation, to replace all of our gasoline (and I know thats just gasoline) with this potential solution. We just need action, over business as usual. I figure I can meet all of my needs with the area in my back yard. Can anyone tell me how to make my own algae pond to make diesel fuel? I believe there was a site out there were Savinar was trying to debate some of these biodiesel guys, I felt they held their own, in theory, I have yet to see any results yet though. Ah yes, found the link, it was this guy, Michael Briggs:

http://www.unh.edu/p2/biodiesel/article_alge.html

It seems like a lot of water. 56k square miles is bigger than Lake Superior and Lake Huron combined.

yes but how deep is it?

I don't think it has to be very deep to be a problem. If you're talking about flooding an area the size of the state of Iowa to a depth of several inches, and then replacing the huge amount of water that evaporates every day, you're talking about water use on a scale that is mind boggling. We're already having trouble getting enough fresh water to irrigate the crops we already grow.

Profitable algae to biofuels has not been accomplished. It is like solar photovoltaic cells and making electricity. It can be done but is not practical or profitable on a large scale compared to more competitive power generation. Cellulosic ethanol is so far from profitable it might bankrupt any nation attempting to convert to it.

One idea I saw took advantage of the fact that algae only needs around 1/10th of the amount of sunlight to grow, the rest causing the algae to need agitating to bring the algae which has not been exposed to the surface up and submerge the stuff on the top that has had its dose of sunlight.

That takes energy, and makes the process expensive.

the idea is simply to pipe the sunlight in with optic cables in the right amount, so you would have a building with several levels, each with tanks of algae, and each would get the correct amount of sunlight and would simply need skimming to harvest, and then drying.

Doing things indoors would also reduce evaporation.

homebrew -

I've looked into algae only superficially, but I think that with regard to the large scale production of biodiesel from algae, several questions are highly pertinent to its feasibility and cost-effectiveness.

1) While high-lipid strains of algae can be grown in enclosed bioreactors under highly controlled conditions, can an algae 'monoculture' realistically be maintained under steady-state conditions in an open pond, where a natural 'ecology' of various strains of algae plus other oganisms will eventually establish itself?

2) What is the maximum algae concentration that can realistically be grown in an open pond under the conditions of a) no mechanical agitation, and b) mechanical agitation provided?

3) Related to (2), what is the maximum algae concentration that can realistically be grown in an open pond while still maintaining aerobic conditions with a) no mechanical aeration, and b) mechanical aearation provided?

4) What are the nutrient requirements in terms of lbs NPK per dry-weight lb of algae produced? How are these nutrients to be provided?

5) What are the best methods for extracting the lipids from the algae, and what are the material handling considerations and energy requirements of such?

6) If we assume an algae lipid concentration of say 25 % by dry weight, then after lipid extraction we are left with 75% dry weight of organic algae mass. How is this large amount of highly biodegradable (and hence oxygen-demanding) material
to be handled and disposed?

My gut feel is that the large-scale growing algae in enclosed reactors will prove to be a technological deadend due to economic reasons and that unless high-lipid algae can be successfully grown entirely in open ponds, biodiesel from algae will go nowhere. Having said that, I am more than willing to be proved wrong.

Great list of questions, to which I add: How much energy is used in the process of drying the algae, which must occur before any additional processing?

At ASPO-USA Denver, I talked with one of the NREL reps who spoke there and being very interested in algae biodiesel production asked his opinion. He identified joule's list and my addition as the big problems in getting a decent EROEI for the process. He thought cellulosic ethanol more realistic IF a lowcost enzyme process could be established instead of the very costly--both in $ and EROEI terms--acid process (there's a process using water, but it takes too much time for the reactions to occur for any degree of high throughput/yield/scale).

I know of at least one company trying to prove you wrong. They plan to used large ponds covered by an inflated plastic dome. Separation of the oil does not require the algae to be dry. Simply dissolving the cell walls or mechanically breaking them to release the oil allows the oil to rise to the top. The remaining wet fraction could be fermented into methane.

I was very hopeful of algae-biodiesel to the point where I wanted to build my own "refinery" in 2005 prior to my talk with the NREL man. Have any you seen this popst at RR's blog, http://i-r-squared.blogspot.com/2007/05/algal-biodiesel-fact-or-fiction....

thomas deplume -

Yes, you can cover a large pond with an inflatable plastic dome, but the practical limit for each dome is probably not much more than an acre or so. However, algae biodiesel production facility of even modest size would require hundreds or thousands of acres.

The more I learn about these algae schemes, the more I'm convinced that there are very daunting scale-up obstacles, particularly in the area of material handling.

For example, let us take a quite modest algae biodiesel operation with a production capacity of say 100 barrels per day. At about 7 lbs per bbl 100 bbl/day is about 29,400 lbs/day of oil. If we assume that the algae we're growing has a lipid concentration of about 25% by dry weight, then we will need to grow about 118,000 lbs/day of algae.

I don't really know what the maximum algae concentration is practical for large pond, but I tend to doubt that it's much more than 1% by dry weight (doesn't sound like much, but 1% is VERY green and opaque water). If so, than that means we will have to handle 11.8 million lbs/day of algae-containing water. To harvest the algae that amount of water would have to be put through some sort of liquid-solid seperation step (or steps) prior to lipid extraction. The concentrate (say 30% solid by weight) would then go through lipid extraction and separation, and the spent algae cells sent to their final disposition (perhaps anaerobic digestion.

We are thus handling a very large quantity of aqueous goop to produce just 100 bbl/day.

Algae will contain on the order of 6% nitrogen and 1% phosphorus (give or take). Thus, in order to grow 118,000 lbs/day of algae we will need to supply over 7,000 lbs/day of nitrogen and almost 1,200 lbs/day of phosphorus. If these nutrients are to be supplied by sewage treament plant effluent, then a very large flow rate of sewage will have to by pumped through the pond each day.

Again, all this is just to produce 100 bbl/day of oil.

While, the above numbers can be noodled around with, I do think I am at least in the right ball park. My main contention is that while material handling and algae separation may be trivial on a lab scale, it becomes a very big deal once you are in the realm of even modest production levels.

errata:

Should read " ... at about 7 lbs per gallon, not 7 lbs per bbl.

You make some good points. But how do these factors compare to the water and natural gas used by the Alberta tar sands or the 99% water cut in some oil fields? Whether it is biofuel or rock oil there are enormous capital investments involved. As for a limit on the size of an inflated dome the Pontiac Silverdome covers 13 acres. Not that I believe anything that big is necessary the minimum practical size needs to be worked on. The different methods of production different companies are trying will answer all your questions in the next few years. Even if one method proves to be a big success the area that needs to be covered each day for the next few decades according to my calculation is around 10 square miles. Fortunately the ponds can use land not suitable for agriculture, uses only 10% of the water per acre that corn or beans would, and can utilize brackish water sources which are in abundant supply. Unfortunately there is not enough time left to upscale any method found to be practical.

You just knew Wing Nut Daily would jump all over this, and to the wrong conclusion...

New tests could further undermine 'fossil fuels'

Scientists who have confirmed that abiotic hydrocarbons are being released from the Lost City hydrothermal field in the Mid-Atlantic range at the bottom of the ocean say they are returning to that location this summer to try to confirm the presence of more complex hydrocarbon chains, a result that would further undermine the assumption that oils are the result of decomposed and compressed organisms.

Should solve any problems, in a few million years!

More seriously, it would have implications for where you looked, although some years ago a test rig, in Sweden I believe, did not discover the oil they had hoped - if my memory serves me correctly though there may have been some doubts about the methodology, how deep they went and so on.

The Siljan Ring Complex:

The location:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Siljan

T Gold ‘they just did not drill deep enough’…

http://www.science-frontiers.com/sf069/sf069g09.htm

No Free Lunch:

http://www.copvcia.com/free/ww3/102104_no_free_pt1.shtml

More Stuff: (goes on about the lost city as well)

http://www.geotimes.org/oct05/feature_abiogenicoil.html

Dont hold yer breath...

Actually, we are creating the "stagnant ocean senario" supposed to have created the oil we burn today. If we harvest the biomass growing in the stagnant ocean and convert it into hydrocarbons to burn, we can push this global warming thing beyond anything this planet has ever seen. Frankly, I don't handle heat very well, I got heat exhausted in Vietnam and it hurts to get overheated now. I know from personal experience what slowly dying this way would be like. Trust me, you best be looking for ways to cool the planet off, rather than ways to slow the warming. Humans will cease to exist(and most other species, except perhaps those around the heat vents on the ocean floor).

http://cid-yama.livejournal.com/65573.html

"Further" undermine? What's the other evidence? That a little bird told him?

That oil is found at the bottom of the ocean, when no dinosaurs ever walked there.

I kid you not, that's his idea of "evidence."

For those who haven't been following this story, he's referring to this study in the very reputable Science.

However, the scientists in question were not interested in the origins of oil, as Corsi implies. Rather, they are interested in the origins of life.

I think most scientists agree that abiotic oil may exist. What they deny is that it exists in "economically interesting accumulations."

Just went over this with a guy from libertypost.

Peak Oil, Deep Oil and Son of the Evening Star -- Part I

Peak Oil and Deep Oil, Part II

http://oilinvestor.blogspot.com/2006/03/peak-oil-and-deep-oil-part-ii.ht...

"And the most recent volcanic flows at Yellowstone were a rock type called rhyolite, which is chemically equivalent to granite, except that granite is what you get if the rock cools and crystallizes at depth. That is, in a few million more years, the subterranean source of this molten material at Yellowstone might cool to become what we call granite. Then again, Yellowstone could also erupt upward in one of the largest volcanic explosions in geologic history. We will just have to wait and see. And maybe you will even read about it in The New York Times, if you are patient.

But what we do not find in Yellowstone is oil or gas. Despite the connection to a "hot spot" in the Earth's crust, there is nothing that even remotely could be called an oil or gas deposit. And the best science is that whatever is down under the ground at Yellowstone will never become oil or gas."

i think that oil from dinosaurs theory is the result of old chevron adds from the '70's.............................but apparently lots of people buy it.
and further back, anyone remember sinclair dino ? they had a green dinosaur, i think.

Yes, the mascot of Sinclair is a green dinosaur. You can still see some Sinclair gas stations out west. There's a refinery that's theirs too near Rock Springs, WY (or it might be Frontier, I forget exactly).

*edit* Oh, I just looked at the map. The refinery is in Sinclair, WY. Wonder who owns that one? :)

There have been plenty of chemical studies that show one can reduce carbon monoxide or carbon dioxide via Lewis acid catalysis — Fisher-Trope type processes — and get a variety of aliphatics (hydrocarbons).

However, evidence for the feasibility of a chemical process is not proof that nature produces her chemicals in that way.

This a very common in the chemical literature. A chemist will prove that a certain chemical process produces X and since X is a molecule in nature he asks the reader to wonder if nature uses that process.

As far as I can tell no one has shown there is a correlation between the feasibility and actual practice of Abiogenic means to produce oil.

Oh, and if an Abiogenic process does prove a fruitful theory for explanation of oil it still does not begin to address rates of production.

Cocktail napkin math on abiotic oil:

Barrels of oil used per day (2004): 84,000,000
Oil consumption in liters per year: 4,874,940,000,000
Which equals: 4.87494 cubic kilometers
Volume of all the oceans: 1,347,000,000 cubic kilometers
Number of years to fill all the oceans: 276,311,093
Estimated age of the earth: 4,500,000,000

If abiotic oil production is for real, there are several oceans worth of oil hiding down in the core of the earth, the abiotic production of oil is a really really recently started process, or it is happening too slow to make any difference to us.

(Or my math is off... it's bedtime)

I imagine this question has been covered till eyes roll, but anyway here it is again:

As 'easy' oil to produce is replaced by 'harder' oil, there would be be an energy loss, where or how is this accounted for in world production? Before, after, not at all?