DrumBeat: April 20, 2008


Michael Pollan: Why Bother?

Why bother? That really is the big question facing us as individuals hoping to do something about climate change, and it’s not an easy one to answer. I don’t know about you, but for me the most upsetting moment in “An Inconvenient Truth” came long after Al Gore scared the hell out of me, constructing an utterly convincing case that the very survival of life on earth as we know it is threatened by climate change. No, the really dark moment came during the closing credits, when we are asked to . . . change our light bulbs. That’s when it got really depressing. The immense disproportion between the magnitude of the problem Gore had described and the puniness of what he was asking us to do about it was enough to sink your heart.

Sticker Shock in the Organic Aisles

Organic prices are rising for many of the same reasons affecting conventional food prices: higher fuel costs, rising demand and a tight supply of the grains needed for animal feed and bakery items. In fact, demand for organic wheat, soybeans and corn is so great that farmers are receiving unheard-of prices.

But people who have to buy organic grain, from bakers and pasta makers to chicken and dairy farmers, say they are struggling to maintain profit margins, even though shoppers are paying more. The price of organic animal feed is so high that some dairy farmers have abandoned organic farming methods and others are pushing retailers to raise prices more aggressively. Several organic manufacturers worry that sales may slow as consumers cut back.


Food (and fuel) for thought

Fertilizer production is second only to petroleum refining when it comes to industrial use of natural gas in the United States: 97 percent of the fertilizer applied to crops is manufactured from natural gas. With spiking energy costs, fertilizer manufacturers are opting to close their doors and instead sell their natural gas supplies. Fertilizer prices are climbing as a result.


Oil hits record $117 a barrel

According to analysts, the refiners in America are trying to create an artificial shortage of gasoline and other distillates. Gasoline supplies have declined over the past five weeks to the lowest since January as refiners cut their processing rates.


Growing world needs every form of energy-Shell

Netherlands - ROME (Reuters) - The world will need every form of energy available -- from coal to biofuels -- to keep pace with a booming population, the chief executive of Royal Dutch Shell said on Sunday.

Jeroen van der Veer also said record oil prices, which hit $117 a barrel on Friday, had yet to curb the thirst for fuel.

"... Despite high prices, demand is not dropping, there is only slower growth. Easy oil and easy gas cannot supply all that surge in demand," he told reporters on the sidelines of the International Energy Forum.


Businesses in Bay Area May Pay Fee for Emissions

SAN FRANCISCO — Air quality regulators in the San Francisco Bay Area appear set to begin charging hundreds of businesses in the region for their emissions of heat-trapping gases.

It is believed to be the first time in the country that any government body would charge industries directly for emissions that contribute to climate change. The regional agency that is considering the fee, the Bay Area Air Quality Management District, would be effectively leapfrogging the continuing debate in Sacramento and Washington over how to control emissions.


Plant may avoid emissions curbs

Of the fuels commonly used to run power plants, none releases more of the global-warming gas than coal. In the Southeast, coal produces more electricity than any other fuel.

In the past several years, power companies have pushed to build more than 150 coal-fired plants. But with Congress poised to restrict carbon-dioxide emissions and a trend toward greater environmental concern, some analysts say the boom may be fizzling.


Now’s time to cut back

It’s high time to go on strike. I’m not talking about some union local or a guild out in California. I mean a comprehensive and all-inclusive national strike.

And a week on the picket lines won’t do. This might take a while, and it might require a long-term change in lifestyle. But it does not involve staying home from work, or anything that will hurt household finances or the economy. In fact it will increase disposable income and help our nation’s economic health.

I’m talking about an energy-consumption strike, a flat-out commitment to substantially decrease use of every kind of energy that we, as a nation, have come to waste, so blatantly.


Leafonomics

In poor countries around the world, there’s money being made by cutting down forests. Should these countries be paid not to cut down their forests? Such a curious transfer of wealth may represent the next twist in the politics of climate change.


World Oil Production: Continued Stress

As an engine of economic growth, the availability of oil is seen as a strategic necessity and has been highly politicized on a global basis. Governments compete for limited energy resources to drive their economies. This raises the question as to whether future supplies will be sufficient to meet what seems to be insatiable demand. The concerns have reached epic proportions as an increasingly tight energy supply situation has raised prices for these products, which are competing for consumer’s disposable income. By raising input costs not only for heating and transportation but also across the commodity spectrum, capital flows and trade the world over are affected.

Many pundits believe that we have reached peak production of oil. Basically, wells are being depleted faster than new reserves of oil are being found. These fears have been amplified by the difficulty many oil companies are having maintaining recoverable reserves. Large oil fields such as those in Mexico and in the Alaskan North Slope are in decline and nearing depletion. New finds have been increasingly difficult to come by.


In Mexico, a tempest in an oil barrel

MEXICO CITY — Leftist politicians have shut down Congress, staged hunger strikes and rallied tens of thousands in the streets to fight what they call the "privatization" of the state-owned oil company, Petróleos Mexicanos.

All that in just nearly two weeks since Mexican President Felipe Calderon unveiled his oil reform proposal.

But the protesters might be wasting their time.

Under the tepid provisions of the bill, few private companies are likely to scramble for a piece of the Pemex pie, industry executives and analysts say.


Mexico's Unfinished Reform

THOUGH YOU wouldn't know it from listening to the Democratic presidential candidates, Mexico's biggest economic problem is not the North American Free Trade Agreement but its failure to open its economy even more widely to investment and trade. The single largest obstacle to Mexican growth is the country's state oil monopoly, Petróleos Mexicanos, or Pemex. Created in 1938, the company has become synonymous with inefficiency and corruption; though it supplies 40 percent of Mexico's government revenue, its production has declined 10 percent in the last three years, largely because it lacks the capital or expertise to tap offshore oil reserves.


The Global Inflation Wave and OPEC's Role

A few points need to be pointed out before discussing the issue at hand. First, the global wave of inflation affecting commodities and the current global economic crisis have nothing to do with oil prices. The fact is that the causes behind the rising prices of foods include result from many factors; the rising standard of living standards in major Asian countries such as China; the commercial production of bio-fuel in the United States which has diminished the area of agricultural plots dedicated for growing wheat and barley, and hence the shortage in the supplies of wheat available for bread and pastas; the rise in international prices despite the expansion of areas dedicated for the growth of corn since huge amounts of the produce have been allocated for the production of bio-fuel rather than as animal feed, and this in turn has led to a decline in the volume of meat supplies in the market and to price increases.


Terminal first in nation

The nation's first new onshore terminal for liquefied natural gas in nearly 30 years received its inaugural world shipment last week in Cameron Parish.

Situated on the Sabine-Neches Waterway in the city of Cameron, the new Sabine Pass LNG Terminal will be the largest in the world because of its regasification capacity, and each day could send out the equivalent of 5 percent of total U.S. natural gas consumption, or more gas than all of Louisiana consumes in one day.


Is Hyperion worth it?

"It's just going to create a horrendous amount of traffic,'' Cody said of the proposed oil refinery and power plant, envisioned for a rural Union County site less than a 10-minute drive from his Main Street location. "Whether it'll be good or bad, I'll let you know after I see it and after I get through it."


All Atmospherics, No Climate

When they finally got around to the issues, they were the same ones that we’ve heard before: Who would best deal with an economy hobbled by predatory banks giving mortgages to anyone who could sign their names? How can we most quickly exit the Iraq debacle? Who would offer more tax relief for the not-so-poor while imposing the fewest new taxes on the not-so-wealthy?

Worthy issues all. But one was missing: the environment.


Going climate neutral

Faced with this challenge, we are beginning to hear the catch phrase “going climate neutral.” HSBC claims to have done it. The University at Buffalo is promising to do it as a result of signing the American College and University Presidents Climate Commitment. Professional architects are aiming at it with Architecture 2030, a program calling for all new buildings to be climate neutral by 2030. Environmentally aware individuals or families can do it, too. Here’s how to achieve a climate neutral lifestyle.


Is this the end for cheap airline fares?

The changes hit home last month for Chicago technology executive Ian Drury, who saw the price of a ticket to India that he had planned to purchase jump $1,500, overnight.

"It's definitely a much tougher world for the business traveler as a result of increasing fuel costs," Drury said.


The Big Thirst

Oil prices rose above $116 a barrel last week, setting another record for the world’s most indispensable energy commodity. What was striking about this latest milestone was what didn’t happen: there was no shortage of oil, no sudden embargo, no exporter turning off its spigot.

...“This is the market signaling there is a problem,” said Jan Stuart, global oil economist at UBS, “that there is a growing difficulty to meet demand with new supplies.”


Review: Reinventing Collapse by Dmitry Orlov

...Orlov points out that because we are so identified with owning a car as part of this American middle class identity we will be hard put to let it go. And when we are forced to (due to diminishing and increasingly expensive gasoline supplies) so will go the myth of the middle class. In turn he explains how the Russians lost faith in the classless worker's paradise because they could clearly see that there was an elite strutting around in cool Armani threads. Meanwhile the lack of consumer goods and trendy fashions meant that a good life for all never became a reality.

And because our ideologically indoctrinated minds are so closed to such deep seated change and so invested in our "can do" innovation, we will, like Napoleon, be unable to retreat from the overextended, oil fueled, debt based economy which is poised to come crashing down, financed as it is by foreign investment that will eventually decide that we are not a good credit risk.


As Climate Change Melts Polar Ice, a New World Emerges

So quickly is the ice melting that the prospect of a navigable, ice-free Arctic Ocean is no longer the stuff of fanciful imagination, and has been the topic of two NOAA National Ice Center-sponsored conferences, the April 2001 Naval Operations in an Ice Free Arctic Symposium, and the July 2007 Impact of an Ice-Diminishing Arctic on Naval and Maritime Operations Symposium. Within our lifetimes, and possibly in less than a single generation, we may witness the opening up of Arctic sea lanes that are fully navigable year-round: the strategic, economic and diplomatic consequences will be enormous.


Nigel Lawson loses no sleep over global warming

Nigel Lawson, the Iron Lady’s chancellor, scourge of the miners and father of the adorable Nigella, has joined the ranks of the climate change sceptics. He believes David Cameron’s green agenda is overblown, biofuels are useless and carbon trading resembles ‘nothing so much as the sale of indulgences by the medieval church.’


Review: Book details life after oil, government

Kunstler made his name as an acidic critic of contemporary architecture and landscapes - or as he calls them "suburban crudscapes." He could have used the novel as an opportunity to create cardboard characters that mouth Kunstlerian themes. Instead, he sketches out a scarred world wobbling between order and chaos. Marijuana grows by the roadside, McMansions are stripped for scrap. On a visit to the state Capitol in Albany, Robert finds the lieutenant governor pathetically trying to keep government running with a typewriter and a gun.


OPEC can boost output by 2 million bpd -- Chairman

(KUNA) -- The Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) has the ability to increase its production by two million barrels a day, a senior OPEC official said.

Visiting OPEC Conference President and Algeria's Energy and Mines Minister Chakib Khelil told KUNA the increase could mainly come from Saudi Arabia, adding that other countries like Algeria, Libya, Venezuela, and Nigeria could also contribute in the raise.


No Need for Further Saudi Oil Capacity Expansion — Al-Naimi

ROME, 20 April 2008 — Top oil exporter Saudi Arabia has no plans to embark on further capacity expansion as long-term oil demand forecasts fall and alternative fuel supplies rise, the Saudi oil minister told industry newsletter Petroleum Argus.

The holder of the world’s largest oil reserves sees no need to go beyond its 2009 capacity target of 12.5 million barrels per day “at least up to 2020,” Minister of Petroleum and Mineral Resources Ali Al-Naimi said.


Russian oil drop may be inflating prices

The International Energy Agency has hinted that a 1 per cent drop in Russian output in the first quarter of 2008 is contributing to record oil prices. This is the first time in ten years that Russian production will have fallen.

Analysts say the fall may be anomalous, due simply to high taxes and inadequate reinvestment. Russia is the world’s second-biggest producer of crude oil and one of its main exporters, with reserves of about 40 billion tons, of which 25 billion are on its continental shelf.


UK: Calm urged over refinery shutdown

"Even if Ineos are right and Grangemouth has reduced or even no production for a month there is enough petrol in the UK to cover that."


Shell, Qatar to supply LNG to Dubai from 2010

ROME (Reuters) - Royal Dutch Shell plans to begin supplying liquefied natural gas (LNG) to Dubai in the peak demand summer period from 2010 after signing deals with the emirate and QatarGas, a Shell executive said on Sunday.

Shell aims to supply around 1.5 million tonnes of LNG a year, said Martin Trachsel, Shell's vice-president for gas and power in the Middle East Gulf.


Sinopec predicts 50% decrease in Q1 net profit

BEIJING, April 20 (Xinhua) -- China Petroleum and Chemical Corporation (Sinopec), the country's largest oil refiner, predicted its net profit to decrease by more than 50 percent in the first quarter of 2008 from a year earlier.

...The company said the continuous rise of crude oil price on the global market and domestic price controls led to big losses in refining business and squeezed profit margins.


Petrochina to get its first subsidy, Sinopec warns of profit drop

HONG KONG (MarketWatch) -- China's two biggest-listed oil firms - PetroChina Co. and China Petroleum & Chemical Corp., or Sinopec - said Saturday they expect to receive a government subsidy to compensate for low fuel prices on a monthly basis starting this month.


Gulf Arabs put brakes on buying spree, await bargains

DUBAI/ROME (Reuters) - Gulf Arab exporters awash with cash from record oil income have put the brakes on foreign asset buys as the global credit crisis promises more bargains later and the political spotlight falls on how they invest.

Economists say the battle against domestic inflation in the world's top oil-exporting region is capping spending at home, leaving sovereign funds that invest much of the surplus oil revenue struggling to find a profitable home for their money.


Biofuels won't solve world energy problem-Shell

"The essential point of biofuels is over time they will play a role," Jeroen van der Veer, chief executive of Royal Dutch Shell, told reporters on the sidelines of the International Energy Forum.

"But there are high expectations what role they will play in the short term."


Shell, Exxon Face Higher Oil Production Costs on Carbon Limits

(Bloomberg) -- Royal Dutch Shell Plc, Exxon Mobil Corp. and the rest of the oil industry may face higher costs to exploit Canada's tar sands, the biggest deposit outside of Saudi Arabia, because of efforts to rein in climate change.

A Canadian mandate to bury carbon dioxide when producing the oil may add between $2 and $13 a barrel to the cost of production, according to Pembina, an Alberta-based environmental group. Mining crude from the area now costs around $60 a barrel.


UK: Energy firms to raise bills yet again

Energy companies are preparing to slap hard-pressed households with a second massive hike in utility bills this year. Bills could start rising again in the summer by as much as 25 per cent, or an average £250 per household.

...Last week senior Norwegian energy executives also warned government officials and regulator Ofgem that they do not see the UK as a priority for exporting gas. Norway supplies about one-fifth of the gas consumed in this country. With North Sea reserves dwindling, the UK is facing having to import about half of its gas from countries such as Norway and Russia by 2010.


Pursuing the polluters

An environmental suit may open the door for small countries to take on the multinationals.


Oil firm's drilling plans would encroach on Utah artwork

ROZEL POINT, UTAH -- When artist Robert Smithson assembled a massive spiral unfurling into the Great Salt Lake 38 years ago, there was no indication that this remote spot would be altered again by humans any time soon.

Smithson's work, called "Spiral Jetty," became a world-renowned piece of art, its striking man-made pattern created amid isolation. Now art lovers fear it is threatened by plans to explore for oil a few miles offshore.


Oil Majors Must Rethink Business to Survive, Eni Says

International oil companies must improve their technological expertise to survive a trend of increasing nationalism among nations with energy resources, Eni SpA Chief Executive Officer Paolo Scaroni said.

``The balance of power between international energy companies and producing nations is changing, and not in our favor,'' Scaroni said today in a Bloomberg Television interview at the International Energy Forum in Rome. `` The game is about technology. We need to be needed.''


ANALYSIS - Oil majors forced to accept tough terms

ROME (Reuters) - From Iraq to Ecuador, international oil companies have swallowed their pride and agreed to contract terms they would have walked away from a few years ago.

Oil prices have risen more than five-fold since 2002, emboldening OPEC and non-OPEC energy producers alike to demand a greater share of record revenues and tighten national oil company (NOC) control over the world's biggest reserves.


TABLE - The top 15 oil reserves holders, consumers

United States (Reuters) - Following are countries and companies holding the world's biggest oil reserves, as well as the leading consumers, producers and exporters.


U.S. Midwest Oil Refineries Unharmed by Earthquake

(Bloomberg) -- Refineries in the U.S. Midwest run by Marathon Oil Corp., Valero Energy Corp., BP Plc, Exxon Mobil Corp. and CountryMark Cooperative were unaffected by an early morning earthquake in Illinois.

Marathon, the largest refinery in the Midwest, shut its Potoka crude-oil pipeline as a precaution after the earthquake struck, Linda Casey, a company spokeswoman, said in a telephone interview. The line has returned to service and is operating normally she said.


Exposed: the great GM crops myth

Genetic modification actually cuts the productivity of crops, an authoritative new study shows, undermining repeated claims that a switch to the controversial technology is needed to solve the growing world food crisis.

The study – carried out over the past three years at the University of Kansas in the US grain belt – has found that GM soya produces about 10 per cent less food than its conventional equivalent, contradicting assertions by advocates of the technology that it increases yields.


Across Globe, Empty Bellies Bring Rising Anger

Saint Louis Meriska’s children ate two spoonfuls of rice apiece as their only meal recently and then went without any food the following day. His eyes downcast, his own stomach empty, the unemployed father said forlornly, “They look at me and say, ‘Papa, I’m hungry,’ and I have to look away. It’s humiliating and it makes you angry.”

That anger is palpable across the globe. The food crisis is not only being felt among the poor but is also eroding the gains of the working and middle classes, sowing volatile levels of discontent and putting new pressures on fragile governments.


Biofuels under attack as world food prices soar

PARIS (AFP) - Hailed until only months ago as a silver bullet in the fight against global warming, biofuels are now accused of snatching food out of the mouths of the poor.

Interesting stories and sound bites coming out of the "Energy Forum" going on in Rome. There seems to be a lot of producer nations blaming consuming nations and vice versa for the current oil price predicament.

Also, some perceived frankness coming from OPEC members.

Something to watch in the next several days for sure.

I think energy producers will remain in the driver's seat long after the Rome forum...

Energy producers in driving seat at Rome talks

http://www.reuters.com/article/GCA-Oil/idUSL20434820080420

"The relative positions of international energy companies and national energy companies are changing -- and not in our favour," Paolo Scaroni, chief executive of Italian oil and gas company Eni said in a speech at the opening of the International Energy Forum (IEF).

OPEC member Venezuela, under President Hugo Chavez, has spearheaded a global trend towards resource-holders seeking to maximise their returns from their energy wealth.

Bizarre flooding continues in Bellevue, Ohio
http://www.wkyc.com/news/news_article.aspx?storyid=87593

BELLEVUE -- Beautiful weather, no river, no stream and yet hundreds of residents are flooded here.

No sudden thunderstorms or drenching rains can explain it. For some reason, the earth in Bellevue continues to heave up millions of gallons of water to the surface.

Against gravity and against logic, the flooding continues day after day. Homes and barns suddenly turned into islands trapped in muddy water.

Maybe something to do with the earthquake on the madrid falt the other day?

It's not nice to fool Mothernature!

You may be right.

Did Yellowstone park have similar problems a couple of years back?
I think one of their lakes shifted position.

Also check out the New Madrid earthquake
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Madrid_Earthquake

" As a result of the quakes, large areas sank into the earth, new lakes were formed (notably Reelfoot Lake, Tennessee), and the Mississippi River changed its course, creating numerous geographic exclaves, including Kentucky Bend, along the state boundaries defined by the river.

Some sections of the Mississippi River appeared to run backward for a short time. Sandblows were common throughout the area, and their effects can still be seen from the air in cultivated fields. Church bells were reported to ring in Boston, Massachusetts and sidewalks were reported to have been cracked and broken in Washington, D.C."

Did Yellowstone park have similar problems a couple of years back?
I think one of their lakes shifted position.

Yes, but it happened over an 8 year period, 1994 - 2002.
http://gsa.confex.com/gsa/2006AM/finalprogram/abstract_113148.htm
One end of Yellowstone Lake was uplifted while trees were drowned at the other end. There is only one main lake at Yellowstone, simply called Yellowstone Lake, though there are several much smaller lakes.

The magma chamber is shifting, or even perhaps growing, causing parts of the park to bulge. If she ever blows then it is curtains for at least half of the USA and will push the world into a catastrophic winter that may last for several years. Good stuff here about the volcano including a short video:
http://www.solcomhouse.com/yellowstone.htm

Scientists have revealed that Yellowstone Park has been on a regular eruption cycle of 600,000 years. The last eruption was 640,000 years ago…so the next is overdue. The next eruption could be 2,500 times the size of the 1980 Mount St. Helens eruption.

Hey, an eruption is 40,000 years overdue!

Ron Patterson

There was an interesting story about coal yesterday in the DrumBeat:

http://www.heraldnet.com/article/20080419/OPINION03/149952913

and it had this quote:

To get a better picture of where we were two generations ago vs. where we will be in less than a generation, consider this: in the 1950s the ratio of energy returned in coal-burning power plants to energy spent in coal mining, transporting and processing was 30 to 1. This same ratio is now down to about 3 to 1. In the next 10 to 15 years, for the United States and much of the world, this ratio will be 1 to 1 and coal will no longer be a viable source of power.

Anyone have any idea where these numbers come from, and the degree to which they are accepted?

I can't believe them. In a link a few days ago there was a photo of an 80ft cliff in Wyoming made entirely of coal. The energy ratio of that can't be bad.

Weatherman - You seem to forget that they were talking about the 50's not 2008. Back then they just shipped it to the plant and burned it. Yahoo!

Now they have something called clean coal and environmental regulations or do you think we should suspend those outdated quaint notions?

I think he just made it up. There's been a fair amount of review of coal production & reserves lately (EWG, USGS, Cleveland, Rutledge, etc) and I haven't seen anything that supports that.

A United Nations official called a switch to biofuels; "a crime against humanity."

http://www.nationalpost.com/news/story.html?id=439710

A Green Car Congress article indicated that the United States would need to expand its corn crop more than ten percent and would need to use 30% of the crop for ethanol by 2015. They quoted a yield of 3 gallons of ethanol per bushel while others have stated the yield is 2.7 gallons per bushel.

Canada and some EU nations also require biofuels quotas and worldwide grain stocks are near record lows.

Eating more grain in the diet consumes less grain than eating beef. It takes 8 pounds of grain to make one pound of beef.

Scotland, Edinburgh fuel mini blog

I'll try and keep a wee update on this thread, about how the upcoming strike at grangemouth (shutdown already begun) is effecting real life things in the city.

Technically speaking there is contingency for 77 days fuel so no problem right?!!But....only if folk don't panic buy, which they invariably do. So here goes.

14:30 GMT Sunday 20th Apr mild/small queing at 2 petrol stations. Only slightly more voume than normal for a sunday. Story is splashed across 3 major newspapers now. Times, scotsman, BBC, probably others. Folk will be mulling their afternoon papers just now!

Marco.

Grangemouth Strike Hasn't Hit N Sea Forties Pipeline Yet - BP

LONDON -(Dow Jones)- U.K. oil major BP PLC (BP) said Sunday plant shutdowns at the huge Grangemouth refinery in Scotland ahead of a two-day strike haven't yet impacted the Forties Pipeline System that feeds crude oil into the refinery.
"At the moment, there is no impact," said a spokesman for BP, which operates the Forties Pipeline System. The system moves around 700,000 barrels a day of crude from North Sea oil fields owned by BP and other companies to the refinery for processing and export.
"We're seeking clarification from Ineos and we're assessing the situation," the BP spokesman said.

...A prolonged shutdown at Grangemouth could eventually close down some North Sea oil production which goes through the Scottish refinery through the Forties pipeline, but it is unclear at what point that will happen.

Regarding the stories about Saudi and OPEC excess "capacity" up top, I am reminded of the old joke about the woman who walks in and finds her husband in bed with another woman. The other woman quickly gets dressed and exits the scene. The husband then denies that she was ever there, and the wife responds that she saw the other woman with her own eyes. The husband responds: "Who are going to believe, me or your lying eyes?"

Seems about right...

What kills me is they keep saying things like "increasing production will not reduce prices."

Seems they abandoned reality long ago and are now living in the land of fantasy.

The is a classic emperor has no clothes. It doesn't take a degree in economics (keynesian or otherwise) to figure out that if you dump crude on the market the price will come down.

The embarresing bit for me is the fact none of the media/government/commerce are telling the emperor that he has no clothes - ie that the Sauidis are talking a load of crap. They just keep trying the same old shit cap in hand, begging for more oil, when it is blatantly obvious there is no spare capacity. It is utter self delusion. I don't believe they havnn't figured it out yet " gee maybe they CANT pump more". The frickin' ex saudi oil minister practically spelled it out.

Marco.

Maybe they have capacity, but what scares me is the statement that they don't plan to add new production capacity beyond 12.5 mbpd. And the reason is, among others, alternative fuels. So, they retreat instead of fighting back? Why not flood the market with oil again and kill the alternatives? Didn't they say they could provide 15 mbpd for the next 50 years, if they wanted to? (2004 CSIS presentation, if I correctly recall).
I would really like to believe they are able to increase production so we can buy some time for the transition to non-fossil fuels world. But recently their statements began to look like bad excuses.

Even if they believe themselves capable of raising production to 15 million barrels per day, it may have occurred to them that they are better off saving the oil for the next generation.

At some point it will occur to oil producers that they are sitting on a non-renewable resource that is getting more and more valuable each year. Why should they rush to pump it out?

Especially if they are starting to think that alternative will never be a serious threat - no need to kill them off. Just estimate the (small) contribution they will make, and keep your production at a level that maximises price.

Perhaps there is a growing appeal to being the "last man standing"? A shift in the psychology of producers.

This was all covered last summer and, especially, last October after Sadad al Husseini said they couldn't produce more than 12.5 without damaging their fields. Given he was the director of their production and exploration for 4 or 5 years, I believe him. Given the lack of production to protect OPEC from competition, I really believe him. Given the King's statements about holding back oil (and previous comments), I am certain of it. Given Bush's comments about the production being "not there," how can anyone have even the slightest doubt?

With Russia now apparently back into decline, game's up, folks.

Cheers

Prominent article in the NY Times

The Big Thirst by Jad Mouawad

http://www.nytimes.com/pages/weekinreview/index.html?8dpc

Two word review: geopolitical factors

Jad Mouawad is gradually changing his tone, but he still quotes ExxonMobil as saying that if they were in charge, everything would be fine, to which I always ask, "What about Texas and the North Sea?" Texas and the North Sea: developed by private companies, using the best available technology, with virtually no restrictions on drilling, resulting in respective decline rates of -4%/year and -4.5%year. If oil companies couldn't reverse the long term declines in Texas and North Sea production, why would they be able to reverse declines anywhere in the world?

However, Mouawad did finish the article with this paragraph:

“The country has been living beyond its means,” said Vaclav Smil, a prominent energy expert at the University of Manitoba. “The situation is dire. We need to do relative sacrifices. But people don’t realize how dire the situation is.”

Well, people don't realize the situation is dire because those in positions of responsibility keep passing the buck. IOCs point fingers at NOCs. NOCs say oil is undervalued. Washington points to OPEC. OPEC points fingers at 'speculators' and whistles past the graveyard by saying 'oil and supply are balanced.' Supposed watchdogs like the IEA and the EIA are changing their tune slowly, but it's like turning the Titanic to avoid the iceburg -- the inertia they created with their 'trillions of barrels in reserve' research is too great to overcome. So as they try to gradually change course, they just keep plowing on into disaster.

The current situation is a classic case of denial. To mix metaphors, I think it's pretty obvious that signs of the approaching tsunami are now visible. The harbor is drained of water and there are ominous ripples on the horizon. A few smart people are running for the hills. The rest are standing -- staring in awe at the thing they never thought would happen, that can't possibly be happening NOW. What's even worse, if you want to carry the analogy, is that the Tsunami warning buoys are going off like gangbusters but the 'radio experts' are saying it's a false alarm...

The nature of a catastrophe is that it catches people by surprise. In the world, long periods of boredom are punctuated by awful, brief, periods of disaster. Human beings, so long removed from the natural world, have been conditioned to happily ignore signs of trouble. It is the neurosis of our civilization and may well be the end of us.

I'm not a doomer (yet). So best hopes for people pulling their heads out of their asses.

I'm not a doomer (yet). So best hopes for people pulling their heads out of their asses.

Glad to hear it. Just one small question.

Can you point to a single instance in history where a civilisation has seen a natural disaster coming over the horizon and has acted far enough in advance to avoid the disaster?

Just one?

If not, what's special about this time?

"The animals went in two, by two by two..........." :-)

Yabbut, How The Heck Are We Gonna Fit These Dinosaurs In?

A number of disasters have been stopped dead in their tracks by organizations whose mission is to do just that. Disease outbreaks, for example, were handled very well by the CDC and WHO throughout much of the 20th and early 21rst centuries.

Given, there are diseases that, if they arose, may well overwhelm the ability of agencies to respond. But the organizations are on the ball and ready to respond rapidly in the event of, say, another outbreak of pandemic influenza which does have the potential to overwhelm systems and infrastructure. But if this thing were coming down the line, you'd better believe the agencies would be on their toes doing their best to stop, delay, mitigate, and re-establish function.

To carry the analogy, Peak Oil, represents that kind of a threat. I don't have a crystal ball, so I don't know what the long term affect of Peak Oil will be. We can guess but we don't really know until we've passed through it.

But I do believe we had a number of opportunities to prepare earlier and failed to. The response has shifted from the preparation phase and into what I would term mitigation. In my opinion, I think, through proper mitigation we can salvage large portions of our civilization -- if we act to mitigate now.

So don't start celebrating yet. I won't be a doomer until I see civilization destroyed in large part by the thing approaching. Doing my best right now to help friends and family prepare.

Best hopes for not becoming a doomer.

Rob

In my opinion, I think, through proper mitigation we can salvage large portions of our civilization -- if we act to mitigate now.

It baffles me why people seem to think that salvaging the very thing that caused the problem will mitigate the problem. "Civilization" as we know it has been an unmitigated disaster. It has sponsered a mass extinction episode on an order previously only triggered by large extraterrestrial bolide impacts. It has allowed a single species to boost its population far beyond the carrying capacity of the biosphere, to the detriment of ecosystem integrity worldwide. It has poisoned the atmosphere & surface oceans with oxidized carbon pollution. It has spawned inequitable distribution of resources and countless wars. It has engineered an artificial environment in which people are miserable. Be assured that your best efforts to "salvage civilization" will be countered by the efforts of equally determined & capable people who seek its demise.

FF consumption causes the problem not human civilization.

What baffles my mind is the number of people who seem to want vast numbers of their fellow humans to perish.

"Be assured that your best efforts to "salvage civilization" will be countered by the efforts of equally determined & capable people who seek its demise."

So you confirm my original suspicion. If you are successful many will die.

"What baffles my mind is the number of people who seem to want vast numbers of their fellow humans to perish."

What baffles my mind is the number of people who confuse predicting something with desiring that thing.

People are waking up to the notion that civilization, BAU, idustrialization, etc is the problem. Their desire is not a massive die-off of humans but a desire to save what is left of a rapidly dying planet.

The current model of humans exploiting the natural environment to create lavish lifestyles of the rich and famous is dead!

Will "The Monkeywrench Gang" ride again? It already is.

The idea is to try to ramp down human population through birth control, and a minimum of actual die-off. The gentlest form of die-off will be decreased life expecta