DrumBeat: August 17, 2008
Posted by Leanan on August 17, 2008 - 9:32am
Topic: Miscellaneous
Peak oil is coming, and we're unready
Has the world already reached peak oil, a time of permanently high oil prices and shortages that will profoundly change our way of life? The answer, I think, is likely yes, but the proximity of this catastrophe is not the most important question to ask.Oil is a finite natural resource; sooner or later, the supply will peak. Jeroen van der Veer, chief of Royal Dutch Shell, earlier this year predicted 2015 as the year the world reaches peak production. John Hess of Hess Corp. said: "An oil crisis is coming in the next 10 years. It's not a matter of demand. It's not a matter of supplies. It's both."
Whether peak oil is already here or on its way, we'll have to deal with it.
Shock waves spread as oil bubble bursts
THE exposure of the oil price boom as a speculative bubble has been the catalyst for a change in world financial flows, and the ripples are now spreading through currency, commodity and financial markets.
Giving Our Children a Gas Crisis of Their Very Own
The class of ’08, having survived one of the most bruising college admissions seasons ever, will face an even tougher real world four years hence. Though Barbara Ehrenreich’s best-selling book on the ordeals of low-wage American workers, “Nickel and Dimed,” was required summer reading in high school, Sam grudgingly admits that he’s privy to a more affecting set of economic indicators when he punches the time clock.Some of his co-workers have lost their homes in foreclosure; others have lost their cars. One young man parks his car at a different pal’s home every night — just a step ahead of the repo man. There are more and more employee scooters and bikes in the market parking lot. With no bus service available, some adult workers with families have begun the grim calculations as to whether they can afford to keep jobs half an hour’s distance from home.
Oil companies pull workers on threat from storm Fay
HOUSTON (Reuters) - Shell Oil Co and Marathon Oil Corp pulled nonessential workers from the eastern and central Gulf of Mexico due to the threat of Tropical Storm Fay, but offshore production was unaffected, the companies said on Sunday.Shell said about 200 workers were evacuated on Sunday from the eastern Gulf, the same number the company evacuated from that region on Saturday. Marathon said the number evacuated from the central Gulf was not immediately available.
Drilling for Oil Way, Way Offshore
Whatever that means for offshore drilling in the U.S., the real victims of the global thirst for petroleum will be overseas — areas that, until the recent price rise, were too remote and forbidding to be worth drilling. Case in point: the vast, impenetrable western reaches of the Amazon.
Richard Heinberg: Losing Control
The trajectory of our relationship with control is about to change. With the end of cheap fossil fuels, and therefore the end of cheap energy, our ability to control our environment begins to wane. This of course has abundant practical implications, but also a collective psychological, even spiritual impact.Once we lived with a sense of our own limits. We may have been a hubristic kind of animal, but we knew that our precocity was contained within a universe that was overwhelmingly beyond our influence. That sensibility is about to return. Along with it will come a sense of frustration at finding many expectations dashed.
Iraq likely to abandon short-term oil contracts - US
Iraq - BAGHDAD (Reuters) - The Iraqi government is likely to abandon plans to sign short-term contracts with foreign oil companies, negotiations over which have been halting, a senior U.S. diplomat in Baghdad said on Sunday."It appears that on present form (the Iraqi government) probably won't proceed with most of these or all of them," Charles Ries, coordinator for Iraq's economic transition at the U.S. embassy in Baghdad, told reporters.
Fiji: Canned food runs out on Rotuma
SHOPS on Rotuma have run out of canned food as a result of poor shipping services.Itumuta villager and shop owner Kensington Fatiaki said most small shops have run out of tinned fish and meat.
...In June, shops and supermarkets on Rotuma ran out of food supply and fuel because there have not been any shipping service to the island this month.
Children had to walk up to 10 kilometres to get to school.
Green fuel for the airline industry?
Aviation is uniquely vulnerable to the consequences of peak oil – the point at which global oil production begins its inevitable decline. Whereas land-based transport could in theory be completely electrified, powered by batteries charged from renewable sources, there is no alternative to energy-dense liquid fuels for jet engines. There is a growing consensus that global oil production will peak in the next decade or so and then go into terminal decline. Some analysts believe it already has: output has been essentially flat since 2005 despite soaring demand, which is why the price is heading skyward. Even the traditionally optimistic International Energy Agency now foresees an oil “supply crunch” from 2012. For airlines the problem could soon be not just whether they can afford jet fuel, but whether there is enough of it to go round.
Global warming aside, fresh water dwindling
Climate change has the potential to alter both water supply and demand. According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's Fourth Assessment report in 2007, increasing temperatures suggest increased evaporation and decreased stream flows, as well as rising seas that could contaminate freshwater estuaries and groundwater resources. Increasingly variable precipitation will likely mean more frequent high-intensity droughts and floods and less available rainfall in arid and semiarid regions, including Arizona.
A Push to Increase Icebreakers in the Arctic
A growing array of military leaders, Arctic experts and lawmakers say the United States is losing its ability to patrol and safeguard Arctic waters even as climate change and high energy prices have triggered a burst of shipping and oil and gas exploration in the thawing region.The National Academy of Sciences, the Coast Guard and others have warned over the past several years that the United States’ two 30-year-old heavy icebreakers, the Polar Sea and Polar Star, and one smaller ice-breaking ship devoted mainly to science, the Healy, are grossly inadequate. Also, the Polar Star is out of service.
And this spring, the leaders of the Pentagon’s Pacific Command, Northern Command and Transportation Command strongly recommended in a letter that the Joint Chiefs of Staff endorse a push by the Coast Guard to increase the country’s ability to gain access to and control its Arctic waters.
Will the Power of 4 ($4 Gas) Fade?
When I sought guidance on what happened on the roads after the last oil shocks, Matt Wald, my longtime colleague and expert on all things that move, sent a link to federal data showing that indeed, driving declined after the 1979 oil disruption, but then resumed its long upward march.
Skyrocketing prices for road salt hammers local municipalities
County municipalities estimated they would need 20,000 tons of salt this winter, but the Central Salt contract does not require them to buy that much or, in turn, prevent them from ordering more if they need it. Most county municipalities wound up needing much more salt than they anticipated last winter, a development that led to severe supply shortages toward the end of the winter as Central Salt struggled to keep up with runaway demand here and across the country.That supply shortage has carried over into this year, contributing to the higher prices, said Larry Googins, president of the Beaver County Regional COG. Also factoring into the increased salt prices are high fuel costs, which are making salt shipping more expensive, Googins said.
“It’s going to be a financial burden for a lot of our municipalities,” Googins said. “We’re not exactly thriving here, and none of the municipalities budgeted for this type of increase.”
Bus route changes help district balance budget
CORPUS CHRISTI — When Anne Benning learned a change in her son's bus route this school year would mean he would have to walk almost the same distance to the new bus stop as to the school, she decided she would stomach the high gas prices and drive him each day.
Asphalt shortage, skyrocketing prices challenge paving industry
Gas prices affect almost everything. Over the past year, skyrocketing fuel prices have boosted the costs of goods and services. Hailing a cab is more expensive in some places, as is buying a sandwich.But the items transported along the country's roads are not the only ones getting more expensive. The cost of the roads themselves are going through the roof.
Driven by a combination of high oil prices and a drop in supply, asphalt prices have more than doubled since the beginning of the year. The sudden and drastic increase has left local paving contractors and municipalities trying to figure out how to compensate.
In Ukraine, Fear of Being a Resurgent Russia’s Next Target
Tensions between Russia and Ukraine have been high for years. Mr. Yushchenko, like Mr. Saakashvili in Georgia, has sought stronger ties with the West, including membership in NATO, which Russia has said would threaten its security. In early 2006, Russia cut off natural gas supplies to Ukraine, in a bold maneuver to weaken Mr. Yushchenko’s government.
Childbirth: Highway Proximity Linked to Birth Weight
They found that compared with living in a wealthy neighborhood farther away, living in a wealthy neighborhood within 220 yards of a highway was associated with a 58 percent increased risk of preterm birth, an 81 percent increased risk of low birth weight, and a 32 percent increased risk of being small for gestational age.
Champion Cyclist and Now Champion Guzzler of Austin Water
Say it ain’t so, Lance.In July, Mr. Armstrong, who won the Tour de France seven times, used a whopping 330,000 gallons of water at his lush Spanish-colonial home, with an acre of gardens and a swimming pool, city water authority officials said.
This tremendous flow of H2O, which is 38 times what the average household in the city uses in the summer, comes as Texas is going through a dry spell and officials are asking people to cut back on watering their lawns.
Suffering is relative for inflation-hit Saudis
RIYADH (Reuters) - With inflation rising across the Gulf Arab region, Saudi Arabia's perennial problem of unequal distribution of wealth has never been so obvious.While poor Saudis queue for hours to obtain water in the kingdom's second city Jeddah, others are able to take advantage of America's new-found disdain for gas-guzzling four-wheel-drives by snapping up imported cars.
Thousands of couples are cutting costs by forgoing individual weddings in favour of mass ceremonies carried out by a charity backed by Saudi princes. But the affluent are still going on holidays, albeit opting for cheaper stays in neighbouring Arab countries rather than trips to Europe or Asia.
Surging oil prices have triggered a turnaround in Saudi Arabia's economic fortunes and a return to some of the big spending -- by wealthy individuals and the monarchy -- that characterised the 1970s and 1980s.
But the economic boom has also stoked prices for food and fuel, leading to discontent in a rapidly changing country where around two-thirds of the 17 million-strong local population are under 30, educated and outspoken and aware of events abroad.
Georgian rail bridge blast hits Azeri oil exports
BAKU (Reuters) - Azerbaijan suspended oil exports through ports in western Georgia on Sunday after an explosion damaged a key rail bridge there.Georgia accused Russian troops of blowing up a railway bridge west of the capital Tbilisi earlier in the day, saying its main east-west train link had been severed. Russia strongly denied any involvement.
McCain: Georgia conflict threatens energy supplies
COSTA MESA, California (Reuters) - Republican presidential candidate John McCain on Saturday criticized Russia's military operations against Georgia, arguing the conflict poses a grave threat to world energy supplies.In his weekly radio address, the Arizona senator said a disruption of energy supplies abroad could raise prices, "inflicting great harm on our economy and on America workers."
France Reaffirms Its Faith in Future of Nuclear Power
Here on the Normandy coast, France is building its newest nuclear reactor, the first in 10 years, costing $5.1 billion. But already, President Nicolas Sarkozy has announced that France will build another like it.Flamanville is a vivid example of the French choice for nuclear power, made in the late 1950s by Charles de Gaulle, intensified during the oil shocks of the 1970s and maintained despite the nightmarish nuclear accidents of Three Mile Island and Chernobyl.
Inflation gets right down to the real nitty-gritty
As energy prices continue to rise, even dirt isn't cheap anymore.
Ethanol byproduct makes cows happy
David Fremark, who operates a feedlot in Miller, S.D., said using distillers grains shaves about 25 percent off the cost of his feed bill. Distillers grains typically track corn prices but in recent weeks have been about 20 percent cheaper."The animals love it," he said. "I don't look at my local ethanol plant as an ethanol plant. It's a feed plant to me."
...Critics say distillers grains are no substitute for a plentiful, inexpensive feed corn supply.
Distillers grains are not readily available in the South and West and it's too costly to ship them there, said Colin Woodall, executive director of legislative affairs for the National Cattlemen's Beef Association.
Windmills split town and families: Fallout from green energy; 'Is it worth destroying a whole way of life?'
He hates the sight and he hates the sound. He says they disrupt his sleep, invade his house, his consciousness. He can't stand the gigantic flickering shadows the blades cast at certain points in the day.But what this brawny 48-year-old farmer's son hates most about the windmills is that his father, who owns much of the property, signed a deal with the wind company to allow seven turbines on Yancey land.
"I was sold out by my own father," he sputters.
Airlines push for homegrown alternative get fuel formula
PHOENIX (AP): With the price of oil still above $100 a barrel, everything from wood chips to chicken fat is being scrutinized as an alternative to traditional fuel. But when it comes to airplanes, finding the right mix poses a special challenge. “When you’re in an airplane, you don’t want your fuel to start solidifying,” said Robert Dunn, a Department of Agriculture chemical engineer who is studying biodiesel jet fuel. The airline industry is aggressively pushing for homegrown alternatives to petroleum-based jet fuel, while leaning on customers with a variety of new travel charges to help control a projected $61 billion industrywide fuel expense this year. A number of alternatives to standard jet fuel have been studied for years, though aircraft manufacturers say the challenge is to find ideas that will work now.
Russia proposes tax hike, oil funds reform
MOSCOW - Russia's Finance Ministry unveiled a draft fiscal strategy to 2023 on Sunday, proposing to raise social security taxes from 2010 and reform the $162 billion oil wealth funds to back up the pension system.Under the proposal, Russia's oil revenues will be redistributed between the liquid Reserve Fund designed to support the budget in case the oil price falls and the National Wealth Fund (NWF), earmarked for riskier investment.
Arctic Tribe Fights Oil Development in Refuge
OLD CROW, Canada—Tribal leaders here have renewed their fight against proposed oil and gas drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge during a gathering in July, the Native American Times reports.
Russia's Georgia Invasion May Be About Oil
The conflict between Russia and Georgia is about borders and political power. But dig deeper, and you may find natural gas, oil and a stronger Russia vying for control of those resources are key factors."They [the Russians] sent a message that Georgia has been their backyard, was their backyard and will be their backyard," said Cliff Kupchan of the Eurasia Group, who has studied Russia and its economy and was a State Department officer during the Clinton administration. "And included in that is control of the energy transportation routes in that area."
For 20 years the gas pipe was not fixed to the wall properly. Now, after the propane blast, it's a problem.
Reduce oil consumption at home
Even if you think that climate change (and all that melting ice) is a hoax perpetrated by woolly headed tree huggers, traditional Yankee thrift would convince you that the smartest course is to cut down on our consumption. We use twice as much oil per capita as the other developed countries, so there is a lot of room to cut.
Kenya: China Strikes Wells of Hope in Kenya
China has spent Sh3.7 billion in an aggressive search for oil in Eastern Province and says initial tests show "positive results", the Sunday Nation can reveal.Industry experts said Chinese optimism is not surprising: oil was discovered at Loperot, 100 kilometres South of Lodwar by Shell in 1992 and the Chinese are prospecting in the same basin.
Democrats waver over offshore drilling ban
Under fire from Republicans, top Democratic politicians in the United States are considering lifting a ban on new offshore oil drilling.The issue is now at the forefront of the presidential election, as Republican candidate John McCain has made allowing new drilling one of the centrepieces of his campaign, claiming that it will help drive down petrol prices.
Book club participants' take on 'The Long Emergency'
It's one thing to assume that technology will find clever replacements to heat and cool us, and for the internal combustion engine to transport all 6 billion of us to our individual daily destinations. But it's quite another to imagine a replacement system for our present oil- and natural gas-based agriculture. In this respect, the agrarian practices of the 1800s will have enormous value to future generations, who will have to feed themselves without the incredible, portable power of gasoline and diesel to run tractors, tillers, threshers and the whole motor pool of modern agricultural equipment.
Part Two Of Frank Rich, Arianna Huffington, & Dwight Garner Are Liars, Deceivers, And Traitors
Peak oil has been kept a corporate and government secret since 1956. We could have been planning for it all along had not a cadre of corporate and government power brokers diverted our public wealth into their self serving strategies.A secret kept for fifty-six years — and one that has to do with husbandry of the very planet and its ability to sustain life? Well, keeping a secret like that is made possible, says Goldman, because Americans, in general, seem averse to contemplating reality. Up until now it’s been easy to get away with it, for as long as energy was cheap we were all free to pursue personal interests and put most everything else out of our minds. But soon reality is going to confront us at every turn. For some, it’s already happening.
Global warming, economic stagnation and growing poverty for a majority of the population, plus peak oil, massive debt and misguided foreign policies are all ticking time bombs.But now that we see them, let's cure them.
Some vintage-car buffs downshifting hobby
Classic-car shows across the USA are still attracting crowds similar or just a bit smaller than previous years this summer. Dream Cruise spokesman Don Tanner says the event is expected to draw more than 40,000 cars and 1 million spectators Saturday, about the same as last year.But owners and organizers say participants are making adjustments, such as going only to shows near home, tweaking their cars for better mileage and skimping on hotels and meals.
US gets ready to blow its economy away
All the fashionable talk is of how fossil-fuels must be replaced by massively subsidised sources of "renewable" energy, such as vast arrays of solar panels, even though a recent study showed that a kilowatt hour of solar-generated electricity costs between 25 and 30 cents, compared with 6 cents for power generated from coal and 9 cents for that produced by natural gas.What is terrifying is the extent to which America's leading politicians seem oblivious to the economic realities of what they are proposing. The readiness of Messrs McCain and Obama to posture in front of pictures of virtually useless wind turbines symbolises that attitude perfectly.
Climate change could sink much of Cape Town
Johannesburg - Climate change could lead to large parts of South Africa's most popular tourist destination being flooded, according to a new study quoted by the country's Sunday Times newspaper.The area around Cape Town would, says the report, have to deal with a rapidly rising sea level along its 300 kilometer coastline, as well as waves up to 6.5 metres high within the next 25 years.



The Book Club responses to the Long Emergency were surprising - nothing about Prii dotting the landscape soon as our salvation, or Plans courtesy of Pickens Or Gore. Maybe they were still reeling from the impact? Or I'm too used to people on the internet dismissing JHK for his Y2K statements or jingoism. Other people I've foisted TLE on have been quite vehement that it was all BS, though.
This was just a short summary. There were some extensive postings (I was took the JHK was mostly right position). Trey Garrison took the opposite position. And we had a debate on the local NPR station in Dallas. Here is a link to the full discussion:
http://bookclubblog.dallasnews.com/
There is a public town hall meeting at 2:00 P.M. today in Dallas:
The Points Summer Book Club may be wrapping up, but you'll have one more chance to share your thoughts. You're invited to an in-person discussion of the book and themes discussed here on the blog:
Who: Book club discussion leaders Rod Dreher, Jeffrey Brown, Trey Garrison and Larry Allums -- and you.
What: The Points Summer Book Club town hall meeting, wrapping up discussion of James Howard Kunstler's The Long Emergency
When: 2 to 3:30 p.m. Sunday
Where: The Dallas Institute for Humanities and Culture, 2719 Routh St., in Uptown Dallas between McKinney Avenue and Cedar Springs Road
I've hosted and taken part in some book and documentary discussions on issues and peak oil, global warming, genetically modified food, etc.
An interesting dynamic happens depending on the mix of people in the group. The more diverse their views on the subject the more time is spent (wasted?) with each side trying to convince the other side that their view is the correct one.
But when the group happens to all share roughly the same view on the subject then the discussion is much more productive! It usually gets deep into ways of dealing with or combatting the problem.
(Maybe when widely different views exist within the group each side sees eachother as the problem and the "combatting the problem" energy is spent on eachother?...)
I've always wanted to particiapate in a good face-to-face group discussion on peak oil and energy issues with a group that shares my views on the subject. That view being that we will eventually muddle through by adapting our culture, economy, society and habits with some rather large and difficult changes. In other words, we will deal with the problem by gradually changing to a very different cuture. It's already happening...at least in my eyes ;-)
Greg in MO
Yes, I think that's why PeakOil.com created three special forums: Doomers Only, Moderates Only, and Cornucopians Only. It just got to the point where productive discussion was impossible. Someone would try to post an idea for mitigation, and the doomers would jump all over the thread, totally derailing it. And vice-versa: someone would post about how we are so screwed, and the cornucopians would show up, posting about how silly doomers are and how the free market will fix it all. After awhile, no matter how interested you are in the topic, covering the same ground over and over again gets tedious. The special forums were supposed to offer a place to get beyond that.
People hear what they want to believe.
All of our efforts here just work on the fringes of our individual existing mindsets. It takes a great deal of time and reinforcement to change peoples worldview by even 20-30%. Then spend a weekend with a charismatic cornucopian and it'll set you back 3 months...;-)
It's a good thing to have an open mind.... just make sure it's not open at both ends.
I don't frequent their forums, but don't they run into the problem we have in all political affairs, that almost everyone thinks they're "middle of the road"?
Not really. People seem pretty aware of where they are on the "Doomatron scale." And there are mods who will move or delete posts as necessary.
Leanan,
I was just looking at the PeakOil.com discussion boards and see lots of interesting topics, but absolutely no seperation by Doomer-Moderate-Cornucopian. Am I really missing something? Are the terms used there different? Do you perhaps see different discussion baords when you sign up and declare yourself in one group or another? Help!
I have admin privileges there, so I'm not sure how it works for ordinary users. But you cannot see the special forums unless you register and log in. They are invisible to guests.
Once you are registered and logged in, I think you have to sign up somehow to get into the special forums. But you don't have to pick only one. You can enroll in Doomers Only, Moderates Only, and Cornucopians Only if you wish.
There's not a lot going on right now. Like TOD, PO.com has seen traffic severely slow with the drop in oil prices. And Doomers Only is by far the most active forum.
I'm a member and logged in, and I don't see these forums.
This is supposedly how you sign up:
Here was my central theme:
Several letters in this morning's Dallas Morning News about the Georgia situation:
http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/dn/opinion/letters/stories/D...
Maureen Dowd of the NYTimes also wrote today on the Georgia conflict:
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/17/opinion/17dowd.html?ref=opinion
I think most people in the U.S. realize two things,
1) Russia's aggression against Georgia, just like the U.S.'s aggression against Iraq, has to do with the control of oil and gas, and
2) The U.S. and Europe's reaction of helplessness is due to two things. First, Europe is dependent on Russian oil and natural gas. Second, Russia has nuclear weapons.
As Dowd said, Russia is not Jamaica.
Is there any doubt?
"BAKU (Reuters) - Azerbaijan suspended oil exports through ports in western Georgia on Sunday after an explosion damaged a key rail bridge there.
Georgia accused Russian troops of blowing up a railway bridge west of the capital Tbilisi earlier in the day, saying its main east-west train link had been severed. Russia strongly denied any involvement."
BP stated yesterday that some oil was getting thru.
The problem for BP is that it must tell the world how oil is getting out of the Caspian.
And then Russia addresses the issue.
Today, zero oil is transiting Georgia.
A scary thought, Russia plus OPEC control about 80 percent of world oil exports.
One reason not to expect a crash in oil prices.
Qatar and Libya talked about reducing oil exports. Russia did something about it !
BTW, if one adds Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan, what % of world oil exports is that ?
Alan
About 86%.
Ha! Ha!
Kind of like when Governor Sterling sent the Texas Rangers in to shut down the East Texas Field.
The natural gas scenario is even scarier.
If Russia can tighten its grip on Eurasia, it will control nearly a third of the world's natural gas reserves. If it can then cement an alliance with Iran, a Russia-Iran axis would control more than 50% of the world's natural gas reserves.
http://www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/international/reserves.html
Just imagine controlling half the world's natural gas, combined with a nuclear arsenal to protect it.
Georgia's geographical position, sandwiched in between the two natural gas powerhouses of Russia and Iran, is rather precarious.
I would expect to see Russia not only flexing more muscle in Eurasia, but also deploying more diplomacy towards Iran. With Russia's backing, Iran should have no trouble continuing to thumb its nose at Europe and the U.S., uniting it even closer to Russia.
A Russia-Iran alliance is much more likely than a Russia-OPEC alliance. Iran doesn't have the huge investments in Western economies that other OPEC countries do. Iran's leadership does not rely on the United States to keep it in power as the Saudi Royal Family does. Iran is already at loggerheads with the U.S.
The only person I've heard who publicly speaks the truth is Alexei Miller, head of Gazprom:
"Georgia's geographical position, sandwiched in between the two natural gas powerhouses of Russia and Iran, is rather precarious."
Why I've said that Russia isn't digging in against Georgia but the US.
And if the US attacks Iran, Russian tanks will be on Teheran's
Northern Border withing hours.
http://www.iht.com/articles/reuters/2008/06/10/business/OUKBS-UK-GAZPROM...
From June 10,2008
What is happening in Georgia is not a sudden hasty action by Russia. It is step one of Russia's response to the US missile defense shield recently agreed to with the Czech Republic and Poland. It has been years in the planning, and I expect that we are only at the very beginning.
When someone like Miller says $250 in 2009 I would regard this seriously, considering he is probably fully informed regarding Russian long term planning.
A severe recession with very high oil prices, someone needs to invent a new word for that! The 2010's are shaping up to be extremely 'interesting times'.
Darwinian, your post points out just how isolated the US is increasingly becoming, as the two biggest oil exporters get ever richer while doing pretty much whatever they want to do. It's power via oil wealth.
What I find fascinating is how impudent the US found itself in the Georgia vs. Russia conflict. Bush demanded Russia leave, however what could he do beyond some harsh rhetoric? Not much, because the world needs their oil. Without it the price would skyrocket and our economy would plummet. We have nothing to barter with beyond a cacaphony of words.
We have to take whatever OPEC and Russia decide to dish out, while the impending decline in oil production, via post peak oil, looms on the horizon.
For Russia it's one of those positive feedback loops.
Peak oil gave Russia the power and leverage necessary to do this.
This, in its turn, will give Russia even more power and leverage.
For the U.S. and Europe, however, it's a negative feedback loop.
Peak Oil's like a loaded gun. It's good or bad depending on whether you're the one aiming the gun, or the gun's aimed at you.
When you add the oil export problem to our financial problems, it doesn't look very good for the United States. If we could only get exports from Canada and Mexico (and whatever other few exporters are outside the OPEC-Russia - FSU group), our living standards would go way down. Repaying debt would be a real problem. Even US imports from Canada depend on Canada's ability to get imports to its east coast from Saudi Arabia and other OPEC countries.
I think most people in the US are being misled by propaganda. While oil plays a role in the Georgian agression against South Ossetia (and the Russian counter-attack), I think it is a misread of the situation to think that oil is the primary driver.
The neocons in the US want to assert US hegemony over as much of the world as it can get away with. Access to oil comes with that hegemony (and is a part of the reason for it), but there is more to it than just oil. As such, the primary driver of the events in the Caucasus is the attempt to weaken Russia. The neocons would have got the Ukraine or the Baltic states to attack Russia if they could have (and they might yet get there; they love to get other people to do their fighting for them).
Now, I don't mean to say oil is not a part of the situation. I just think that the primary reason Saakashvili attacked Russian peacekeepers, the primary reason the US wants to get Georgia into NATO, and the primary reason the US wants Georgia to host US missiles is because the neocons see Russia as the biggest threat to American global dominance.
BTW, I think the Russian reaction has been reasonable, if a little harsh. Georgia attacked Russian peacekeepers from positions inside Georgia. Russia needs to make sure that neither Georgia nor other US proxies on its borders contemplate other attacks like that. I also think it makes sense for them to smash as much of Georgia's fancy new US & Israeli weaponry as it can while they is there. Saakashvili has been spending over 4% of Georgian GDP on a massive military buildup, evidently for offensive purposes rather than defensive.
The US could have played the Georgian situation so much smarter than it has (like back S. Ossetian independence, but demand that N. Ossetia be allowed to join it in independence). But in typical fashion, Bush has decided to back an aggressive authoritarian trying to crush a popular movement for independence. Unfortunately for Bush, he's done it to a much smarter agressive authoritarian, moreover one who holds $50 billion in Fanny Mae bonds, roughly 1/2 trillion in dollars, a large percentage of the world's natural gas reserves, and is principal supplier of energy to Europe.
The US needs to be very careful. There is no reason for Putin to be any more willing to allow the US to put missiles in Georgia than Kennedy was to allow the Russians to put them in Cuba.
Heh this is a replay of democrat scenarios during the cold war. "Russia's not comitting genocides and takeovers, it's just responding to western imperialism".
During those times, of course, western imperialism did not gain "the west" (that would be you too) 1 square meter, yet they won Russia countries half the size of the united states ...
But obviously we all know the difference between the american government and the russian one : the american government does not kill people for criticizing it, and the russian one does (and so do muslims and so does china).
So remember people "country X opposes western imperialism" means in reality that they're comitting genocides on innocents, like Iran, Sudan, Russia, and China are doing today. One day it will be your head.
What do you think you will hear when, oh say a muslim, places his "resistance" sword in your neck because, oh, say you're black ? The BBC will state how much you had it coming, and that because of screwing up the earth with global warming, you deserved to be slaughtered.
You know what the truly depressing part is ? After these cowards defend killing you, they too will get slaughtered, and after that, the muslims, Chinese, and russians will ...
Starve to death.
Isn't socialism grand ?
"where men hang their laundry out to dry under the twin moons of the planet Zembar" - Dave Barry
Now, if that doesn't get a person banned...
..we'll know that free speech is still permissible on The Oil Drum.
Oh, please. This is a privately held and run site. If you don't understand you have no rights here, only privileges, well... that's pretty remarkable.
Cheers
Shargash,
The reaction from politicos(Neo-Con op ed writers) in the MSM has been to call for the immediate admission of Ukraine to NATO. These purveyors of "freedom" and "democracy" unfortunately do not respect the will of the Ukrainian people:
In regards to Ukraine joining NATO:
The poll revealed that 54.9% of respondents would vote against joining the military alliance if a referendum were to be held tomorrow, and that 22.3% would back joining NATO.
http://en.rian.ru/world/20080506/106712138.html
MSM accuses Russia of paranoia, apparently they have just cause to be paranoid.
Dan
McCain avers that the Georgian conflict threatens world energy supplies. This is based on a presumption that producers have an inherent obligation to keep the world supplied by energy. This is a tenuous thread upon which to build a future. As far as that goes, the very exis