(Still) Waiting for the Crash in Commodities
Posted by Prof. Goose on May 17, 2006 - 12:07am
Topic: Economics/Finance
Tags: commodities, oil, peak everything, peak oil [list all tags]
Waiting for the Crash in Commodities:
The bull market in commodities, now in its fifth year, is beginning to challenge the laws of physics. Prices as measured by the Reuters/Jefferies CRB Index have not staged a rally this long in more than 50 years.As someone said elsewhere, "the inability of economists to grasp the finite nature of non-renewable commodities never ceases to amaze me." Discuss.



But no, apparently the lines on a chart have mass and are drawn toward its base by the curvature of space-time.
Who knew?
"We live in crazy days," said Juan Eduardo Herrera, vice-president of strategy at Codelco, the world's biggest copper producer. "These prices are not here to stay and nowadays they are causing more harm than good to everybody."
When the major real market (i.e. the physical metal) people say things like that it behooves everyone to pay attention.
yeah, right. just take your mediacation and everthing will be just fine.
and thanks to this apparent "bubble" in commodity prices, the recent pull-back in crude prices found an intraday floor of $68.51 before moving back above $70 again.
stronger US dollar???
correction of all corrections???
i'm sure this would be an outcome that many with vested interests would love to see, but this is surely only possible if the US economy completely melts down.
There is no Law of Bull Markets in Physics as far as I know.
>O.K., let's try real hard to find the cause of this commodities boom, could it be, oh let's see....trying to bring almost two billion people from an animal/people powered society into the modern era in a decade time span? (China/India)....could it be that we came off a commodities collapse in the 1980's early 1990's, so that gold is still cheaper in adjusted inflation terms than it was in the 1970's? Could it be that investors who have gotten their clock cleaned on successive bubbles from the S&L crash (housing collapse? I remember the 1980's....I laugh at housing collapses....HA, HA, HA,:-O), to the internet "tech bubble" crash, to the Euro bubble, to....yep, you got it...someone told them to go "with the hard assets, the metals, the oils, we will always need those (true enough, but when the value of money exchanged on these items begins to wildly exceed the world value of these items, something is getting ready to happen....but, money has to go somewhere, and where to put it? You try to choose, and remember, historically it's not been such a great idea to buy items at historic highs (oil, gas, commodities are getting closer to the all time top)
Let's admit it, the commodities bubble is just that, a bubble, and it shows signs of collapsing even bigger and sooner than the housing bubble...only two wild card holds them this high and that is China/India. Most stats show that if you take these two out, the efficiency of production/use/recycling of commodities has improved in the developed world, and demand has not really risen appreciably. Energy consumption in the U.S. for example has went down, not up, as a percent of GDP...
Which brings us to this dollar thing....I am going to go out on a limb here and say the dollar is not that bad of a bet.
I know, I know, all bets are that a MASSIVE currency collapse is coming, that we will have panic in the street as even hookers and Starbucks will turn down dollars (my creditors are still accepting them, however), and the dollar will fall to nothing compared to.....(???), and there's the rub....compared to what?
Ohhh, that's right, the mighty Euro, the currency of a..."group" (??) of nations several of whom have recently renounced it's own charter....founded by a nation whom, along with it's biggest most powerful neighbor and fellow member run constantly out of complience with all the groups own memoranda of understanding on budget deficits, currency valuation, work rules and interest rates...a group with an aging demographic that is sure to be a greater burden on it's social system than even the U.S. Social Security system faces...and that is, as a percentage of GNP, a bigger importer of oil and gas than the U.S., and with it's only "internal" oil and gas supply dropping like a stone, and with a Muslim minority far greater than that of the U.S., and far more militant and directly connected to the "struggles" for Islamic and Arabic "liberation" than that in the United States.....THE EURO???? !!!!!!
BUT THE CHINESE!! They are coming after us, don't ya' know....of course, they have their own energy woes, and not only that, are driven by exports to....well, mostly us, despite attempts to diversify, because the EU does not fancy being buried in cheap Chinese plastic items after all....and the above mentioned rise in commodity prices mean those cheap plastic items are not so cheap after all....
As I sit typing this, I have the local news on TV, here in central Kentucky....where Toyota is announcing expansion of it's large modern plant in Georgetown KY to build the Camry Hybrid, where Honda is looking at Southern Indiana or Ohio to expand Civic production, and where UPS is expanding before even it's last expansion is finished to cope with increasing air freight to and from the aforementioned China. Now one assumes that Honda and Toyota, selling cars in the U.S., and China, selling everything from Christmas cards to auto and truck brakes in the U.S., fully intend to take payment in....dollars, maybe?
I look at the stock charts....I should have bought oil and gas stocks, right?
Well, only if I ignore Cummins Engine, Caterpiller, and Deere&Co, who have went anywhere from double to triple in the last 3 to 5 years, BEFORE you count dividend reinvestment....who'd a thunk it?
One more thing....try to avoid the phrase "peak everything". It is a clear violation of the terms of true "Peak" and simply makes no sense (peak aluminum? It's recycleable material, and is still cheap enough that you don't even see the homeless and poor out walking the highway to pick up cans...peak iron or steel? Demand is high yes, but Australia alone has enough to provide for a century, they just don't have enough manpower to get it out fast enough...."peak everything" makes those concerned about the real issue of peak oil or "oil and gas depletion" sound silly by association, and borders on "Chicken Little syndrome".
Folks, the depletion of oil and gas are real issues, and deserving of hard, HARD work on replanning our energy system, conservation, and applied engineering. We may need to work on getting a grip here and trying to stay a bit more on topic.
Roger Conner known to you as ThatsItImout
<Funny how you choose the only two commodities, iron and aluminium, that are still in very good supply to make your point.>
Right, as opposed to say Gold, Silver or Platinum, which of course are in short supply because no one bothers to recycle them but just throws them in the landfill...
I grew up on the poor side of the tracks where in the old days of copper plumbing, you were careful who you rented to or they would tear that out of the house and sell it for scrap....
Roger Conner known to you as ThatsItImout
You are spot on. Call a spade a spade and let the masses froth at the mouth. When prices depart vertically from facts it's time to piss against the wind. You will get wet for a while, no doubt, but soon it will be the crowd that will look for umbrellas.
Oil Fact (just one): The daily volume of oil and oil product futures traded in NYMEX and ICE (ex-IPE) alone, currently exceeds global daily oil exports by a factor of 10-to-1. When you add the spot market and the OTC derivatives the ratio gets much bigger. Last year it was 5-to-1; I don't know where the ratio was at the bottom of 1998, but I would guess alot lower. We are getting drowned in paper oil.
The game can be played from the other direction as well, of course; and it has been - oh boy has it ever...
There will be no suden rush to close position due to the finite nature of oil. I think most people here would agree that there will be no price collapse sans some unforseen catastrophic event that produces more oil.
Sincerely,
Hellasious
There is a comment further below about all the futures contracts being used for hedging and therefore their current huge volume is immaterial. That is false for two reasons:
- Hedging involves the transfer of risk: futures trading is a zero sum game. If you win, I lose. So, if you are a producer and sell 1.000 oil contracts short to hedge from its price going down someone else has to assume that risk. That someone is called a speculator. A market needs both, otherwise it cannot function. There are plenty of speculators in this market. How many?
- Assume that every single barrel of oil that was produced and exported in the world was hedged daily. That's some 50 million barrels, or 50.000 contracts in the futures market(1.000 barrels each). The current daily volume in NYMEX and ICE in futures alone is abt. 700.000 contracts (including gasoline, htg oil, etc). Adjust for Sat. and Sun. and it comes to 500.000/day. That is extremely excessive vs. every conceivable hedging requirement and a good measure of just how rampant speculation is in this market, right now. And that is before we take into account the regular OTC spot oil market, listed options and other OTC derivatives. This market is hot and frothy that we should call it..cappuccino.
There are a heck of alot more dots to connect to show the full picture, but I have already taken up way too much space, for which I hope you forgive me.I agree that speculation is certainly influencing the current market. I am just not convinced that it is either hugely significant or necessarily a bad thing.
Can you provide some simple historical data so that one might compare the current level to the year 2000? 1995?
Rampant speculation is extremely significant in shaping prices (just remember dotcoms) and as to good or bad, it depends. Extremes such as these are never "good", in that it is never a good idea to let the tail wag the dog. Or allow Enron (and several Wall Street prop desks) to set prices for electricity in CA - if I may draw an extremely timely parallel.