DrumBeat: August 19, 2007
Posted by Leanan on August 19, 2007 - 9:31am
Topic: Miscellaneous
Raymond J. Learsy: The Oil Patch Cheers On Hurricane Dean
The price of crude oil is down some 8 percent since August 1. What the oil patch and every oil trader knows, one of the quickest ways to turn around this tumble is the drama of a good old fashioned hurricane in the Gulf of Mexico wending its way toward the Texas and Louisiana coasts. And Shazam! Here comes Hurricane Dean!Hurricane Dean's every little ripple will be reported by the oil industry flacks and their willing mouthpieces in the media. The crescendo of ominous events will be forecast and analyzed, all with a unanimity of purpose leading to higher and higher oil prices. Whether the storm actually hits or not, one thing is sure. The mere specter of the event will have the oil industry and the oil trading community cheering, "Go Big Dean, Go".
A free-for-all over oil money in Nigeria
The fire burned strong for 45 days and 45 nights, blanketing the village with ash and torching the young cassava plants in Ada Baniba's field. As she weeded, the flames flared out of the leaking oil pipeline behind her.It wasn't that no one could put the fire out. It was that no one would — not the oil company that owned the pipeline, not the government and not the villagers breathing the fumes.
The tale of Kegbara Dere's fire shows just how desperate the long-neglected communities of Nigeria's oil-rich river delta have become.
The average Nigerian still survives on less than $2 a day, despite the country's $20 billion rise in oil exports to the United States over the past five years. And so Kegbara Dere villagers saw the fire less as an environmental crisis than as a negotiating tool — risking their health, land and even lives to grab their bit of the spoils from the multinational oil companies that rule the region.
Hurricane Dean heads for Jamaica after swiping Dominican Republic
In Mexico the government called a state of emergency and state oil company Pemex launched its hurricane response plan, shutting down production platforms and evacuating personnel, as Dean appeared headed toward its southern Gulf of Mexico oilfields and the refining center of Tampico.
Sacked Iran minister warns of energy 'catastrophe'
Iran's sacked oil minister has issued a parting warning to President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, predicting a looming "catastrophe" in the Iranian energy sector because of high consumption, media reported Sunday."If we do not find a solution to the energy problem in the next 15 years, the country will face a catastrophe," Kazem Vaziri Hamaneh was quoted as saying at his farewell ceremony late on Saturday by the ISNA student news agency.
"I am ready to prove that if the fuel situation continues along current trends we will face an energy crisis in the future," he said. "The current pattern of consumption is a disaster for the country."
Energy policy is kowtowing, not co-operating, critics charge
Canada's approach paradoxical, puzzling. We sell more natural gas to the U.S. than we use.
Oil giants rush to lay claim to Iraq
The world's oil majors will descend on two key conferences about Iraqi oil next month, seizing their last chance to jockey for position before the expected passing of the country's hydrocarbon law sets off a scramble for its vast energy resources.
India: Tough time ahead for refining & exploration companies
The refining margins of Indian refinery and exploration (R&M) majors in the coming quarters is expected to be lower than the first quarter of the current financial year. And if oil majors want to end the fiscal in the black, then oil bonds are necessary. These are but some issues highlighted in a recent Merrill Lynch report in the backdrop of a fall in international crude prices.
ONCE a provincial Soviet town known for its fragrant apples and snow-capped mountains, Kazakhstan's largest city, Almaty, is now engulfed in exhaust fumes and construction sites, an emblem of rapid progress choking on its own oil-fuelled economic boom.
China, Kazakhstan to Build Pipelines From Caspian Sea
The leaders of China and Kazakhstan agreed to finance and build a network of pipelines to supply the world's fastest-growing major economy with oil and gas from the Caspian Sea region.
Canada: Coal plants keeping the lights on
A temporary shortage of electricity from nuclear reactors in Ontario is forcing the province to run its coal plants longer to keep the lights on, causing a spike in greenhouse gas emissions and a potential headache for Premier Dalton McGuinty.
Texas Trader Admits Guilt in Iraq Oil-for-Food Fraud
The trader, David B. Chalmers Jr., admitted that he and two companies he ran, Bayoil USA and Bayoil Supply and Trading, made millions of dollars in kickbacks to the Iraqi government — as well as huge profits — while trading oil under the $65 billion aid program.
World agriculture is at a turning point: energy and climate change are re-defining the global food situation. As demand for affordable energy increases, along with greenhouse gas emissions, bioenergy is increasingly seen as an economically and environmentally sound solution. The growing potential of biofuels appears to create a substantial opportunity for the world's farmers in both industrialised and developing countries.
A blend of new, existing energies
Inexpensive power is important because it is what drives the economy. Low-cost power can give businesses a competitive advantage in the global economy.So it came as good news that American Electric Power recently entered into a 20-year agreement to buy 100 megawatts of wind energy for customers of Indiana Michigan Power and another 100 megawatts for its Appalachian Power unit in Charleston, W.Va.
Mud: building block of the future
New homes built of mud or straw, with a lawn on the roof, sheep fleeces for insulation and heat from the ground or a boiler fired with sawdust – this is one vision of the future for our green and pleasant land.
It sounds good, but turning garbage to energy has downsides, critics say
Drastically reducing the amount of garbage going to landfills while creating a clean energy source in the process - it sounds like the perfect solution to the world‘s environmental woes.But critics argue that the process of heating garbage to create a gas that can then be used to produce heat and electricity - a process known as garbage gasification - is an unsustainable solution to the problem of overflowing landfills that will ultimately cause more harm than good to the environment and human health.
New Field for Earmarks in U.S. Goals on Energy
Enthusiasts call it cutting-edge research on a crucial national priority. Critics of this new genre of federal spending call it “green pork.”
European smart cars kick off national tour
Popular in Europe, the ultra compact cars will be available for sale in the United States next year. Shunning national advertising, the distributors are taking pre-order reservations for $99 online and during road show stops.It's a "grass-roots" effort, allowing potential customers to see, touch and drive the two-passenger cars that start at prices under $12,000, said Ken Kettenbeil, company spokesman.
Hundreds protest in Myanmar over fuel price hike
Pro-democracy activists led hundreds of people in a rare march through Myanmar's main city of Yangon on Sunday, in protest against an enormous hike in fuel prices last week.Myanmar's ruling junta doubled key fuel prices on Wednesday without warning, leaving many urban workers unable to afford the cost of simply getting to their jobs.
Hopes dim for 180 trapped miners in China
More than 180 trapped miners in China have slim hopes of survival as the shafts they were working in are almost completely filled with the raging waters from a broken levee.Officials said on Sunday operations in other coal mines in Shangdong province had been halted as a precautionary measure, a move angry relatives said should have been taken days earlier, underlining the country's reputation as the world's deadliest coal industry.
Sri Lanka: Norochcholai power project will generate 3,000 jobs directly
The balance requirement of around 65 per cent of the country's energy was provided by the existing Diesel-powered stations located in an ad-hoc manner around the country. The escalating costs of oil in the world market by the day, proved beyond doubt that the diesel-powered generator was not the panacea for the aggravating energy crisis.
Federal lawmakers need to move now to make CTL fuel available ASAP
Plenty of deep thinkers were crowded into the Coal To Liquids Coalition conference last week at Glade Springs, and while plenty of technical jargon was put out there, the real message was quite evident — federal lawmakers must get on board quickly for America to realize the multiple benefits the synthetic fuel offers to the U.S.
'N-deal no solution to India's energy crisis'
Nuclear affairs analyst Praful Bidwai is not in favour of the Indo-US nuclear deal. Bidwai vehemently opposed the nuclear deal saying it was not a long-term solution to India's energy crisis."It is going to promote nuclear power which is a very dangerous, highly uneconomical and flawed source of energy which cannot be a long term solution to India's energy security issues. So I am opposed to the nuclear deal," Bidwai said.
West Texas, UT system pushing for first-of-a-kind reactor in U.S.
his small West Texas town that decades ago grew up out of the oil boom now wants to leap into the nuclear age.Though years from becoming reality, a cutting-edge nuclear reactor — the first built on U.S. soil in 30 years — is being pursued not as a power source but as part of an energy research complex that could lead to advances in hydrogen power.
Eighteen miles south of Fayetteville, on the edge of the Ozark National Forest, sits a dilapidated monument to both the promise of nuclear energy and the problems it can create.
Domestic demand set to drive Saudi Arabia's growth to 2010
Domestic demand will be the main engine of growth in Saudi Arabia for the period 2007-2010, according to a report by the Riyadh-based Jadwa Investment.The report, released recently, said that the megaproject implementation and broad liberalisation will push real non-oil private sector growth up to an average of nearly 8 per cent with growth being fastest in manufacturing, communication, finance and construction.
Gaza power plant shuts down amid fuel shortage
Gaza’s main power plant shut down operations on Sunday after the plant said it had depleted its fuel reserves, despite a pledge from Israel to resume deliveries that were halted late last week.Israel opened the Nahal Oz crossing in central Gaza to allow fuel into the Hamas-controlled coastal strip, but power plant officials said the private Israeli fuel company Dor Alon has yet to deliver any fuel.
Jet fuel runs out at some Nunavut airports
Airports in Rankin Inlet, Resolute Bay and Baker Lake are out of jet fuel, while the supply in Hall Beach is running low, according to a Nav Canada notice issued Thursday.As a result, Calm Air had to turn back two flights that day, while the Nunavut government said it plans to fly in more fuel Friday to tide over the Rankin Inlet airport until its usual supply comes in by ship.
Courage must fuel renewable energy
Well, I would submit that all of this is because few of us really want to see energy prices rise to a point where alternative energy is directly competitive with traditional energy. Even though we know, in our hearts of hearts, that nothing serious is going to be done about any of these issues until the economics favor alternatives, we mostly cling to the notion that with the "right" policies, energy prices will drop -- they always have in the past and they well may well fall in the future. Therefore, why worry? Sure a few of us have lowered the price of gasoline to $1.50 per gallon by doubling our mileage with hybrid cars, but most of us still prefer traditional SUVs.
Gulf oil companies prepare for deadly hurricane
Gulf of Mexico oil and natural gas producers were evacuating offshore workers and shutting small amounts of production on Saturday as they watched powerful Hurricane Dean storm across the Caribbean Sea toward an entry into the Gulf next week.Forecasts and computer models point Dean away from the paths taken by 2005's devastating hurricanes Katrina and Rita through offshore oil production areas and onshore refining centers.
Taking a lesson from Katrina, which defied forecasts showing it would confine its damage to Florida, companies with operations from the central to western Gulf continued pulling support workers who were not essential to keeping offshore production running.
Conservationists Cannot Escape the Laws of Energy
I came here to discuss energy conservation with several engineers from General Motors. We wound up talking about religion.That is not as far-fetched as it seems. It has everything to do with the laws of thermodynamics -- that energy can be changed from one form to another but cannot be created or destroyed; and that in all energy exchanges, absent the addition or subtraction of energy from a given system, the potential energy of the changed state will always be less than that of the initial state.
Russia Keeps World Leadership in Oil Extraction
Russia retained the international leadership in oil extraction in June 2007, with a volume of 9.47 billion barrels a day, as reported by the National Statistics Committee Saturday.
Russian gas production falls for 3rd consecutive month
Russian natural gas production dropped for the third consecutive month in July, the Federal State Statistics Service (Rosstat) said on Thursday.Gas production dropped 2.8% in July 2007 from July 2006. Gas output dropped 0.7% in June 2007 compared to June 2006 and 1.8% in May.
Norway: Record low oil production in June
The production of oil on the Norwegian Shelf in June was the lowest for the month in 15 years. The average daily production reached 1,866,000 barrels, against 2,604,000 a day in June last year.
Amid crisis of waste, why not turn valley back to agriculture?
How can Albuquerque survive a major economic downturn brought on by a confluence of drought, aquifer depletion, water pollution, an oil crisis and unpredictable weather patterns? Such a mess is on the way.
The E.U.'s Wind Power Self-Deception
Anyone who keeps half an eye on the world energy scene might have been seriously baffled by some of the recent news from Europe. Since the 1997 Kyoto Protocol agreement on climate change, no government in the world has been proclaiming its desire to save the planet from the evils of global warming more loudly than the European Union, now representing 27 nations.The E.U. has pledged, for instance, to go far beyond its agreed Kyoto targets for reducing its CO2 output, promising to cut its emissions by no less than 60 percent by 2050 (yes, you read that right: 60 percent, in little over four decades). To achieve this highly implausible goal, the E.U. particularly looks to generating its electricity from renewable sources; to this end, it has set itself a target of producing no less than 20 percent of its energy produced from renewables, as soon as 2020.
Hundreds get naked on glacier to expose climate change
Nearly 600 volunteers stripped before the camera on a melting Swiss glacier high in the Alps on Saturday as part of a publicity campaign to expose the impact of climate change.
Climate protesters march at Heathrow airport
Hundreds of climate change protesters marched near London's Heathrow airport on Sunday and pledged civil disobedience to draw attention to the impact of aviation on global warming.Protest organizers say they plan to form a human chain at the site of a proposed third runway at the world's busiest international airport and to picket the headquarters of Heathrow's operator BAA through the night.



Gold Mine of Data on Energy Use by Urban Density
gTrout found the following paper and, on my first reading, I was impressed with the data. I do not have time ATM to analysize properly today, but I would encourage others to download the pdf and digest it.
I think it could form the basis of a good article.
http://dynamiccities.squarespace.com/files-documents/buildings-land-use-...
Best Hopes for Good Data,
Alan
It is true, we really could save a lot of energy and reduce GHG by just abandoning a lot of the low density suburbs and increasing the number of people living in existing urban housing.
" It is true, we really could save a lot of energy and reduce GHG by just abandoning a lot of the low density suburbs and increasing the number of people living in existing urban housing."
Ya' know what? Unless you could figure out a way to make "Pack 'em in like sardines" more attractive in terms of quality of life than rural/suburban living, you'd likely have a serious fight on your hands. You would never get me back in some inner city hi-rise rat trap while I'm alive. Laws, fuel , and eminent domain be damned.
I think it will happen on its own. Probably the only government "intervention" necessary is to turn a blind eye to current local laws about how many unrelated adults can live in one house.
There's no need for the government to force anyone to move. It will happen. People will lose their jobs and/or be foreclosed on. What will they do? Move in with family or friends, many of whom will be glad to have some help with the rent.
Companies also are likely to move back to the cities, where they were before suburbia. There will be workers there who can walk to work if necessary, plus the supply lines that created the cities in the first place.
As we've already seen, when supplies are tight, it's those at the end of the line or out in the boonies who suffer. Cities will have access to fuel, food, jobs, and government handouts that rural or suburban areas won't. People will want to move back to the cities, and if that means sharing an apartment with grandma, grandpa, and your sister's family, you'll do it.
What we have now is a planning and regulatory regime that in most cases mandates low density, separated use, auto-dependent neighborhoods. About one-third of the U.S. market is looking for something different, but government regulation and industry inertia prevent any options from reaching the market.
About one-third of the U.S. market wants neighborhoods with a greater variety of housing types, mixed use, walkable streets and transit access. That proportion is projected to increase due to to demographic factors, and if peak oil and global warming impacts start affecting housing choices those trends will only accelerate.
Best hopes for freedom of choice.
while I'm alive
Male life expectancy declined by 10 years during the transition from the Soviet Union to Russia.
Mortality in New Orleans is about 50% higher today than demographics would suggest.
So that condition may not be a given.
Besides, Americans are herd animals when it comes to housing.
When 25% of your Suburban neighborhood is not merely empty but abandoned, boarded up. overgrown landscaping (perhaps minimal grass cutting to avoid citations), nearest grocery store & dry cleaner closed, sky high property taxes and fewer and fewer services (nearest fire station closes, you cannot remember last time police cruised by your home while crime is *UP*), random power outages, "those people" moving into cheap housing with large families & friends, and squatters starting to show up, you may re-decide.
And as I have stated before, the alternatives are not just Manhattan (or downtown Toronto) or Phoenix/Houston sprawl.
I live in a neighborhood with equivalent energy efficiency to Manhattan. 1 to 3 (a couple of 4) stories tall. A few SFR (single family residences), duplexes and mostly small apartment/condos in subdivided older homes (I live quite happily in 1890 home cut into 6 apartments). QUITE beautiful and walkable (walk score 77 http://www.walkscore.com ) with a streetcar 2.5 blocks away. Unlike the sterility endemic in Suburbia & Exurbia, I know my neighbors.
But I am becoming more convinced that the founding principles of Suburbia were bigotry and fear (certainly white flight was a major force in their founding) and some of that lingers.
Best Hopes for a
DyingChanging Suburbia,Alan
Bigotry and fear were used to promote and justify the suburban life, but they were only tools, not the founding principles. I think the real driver was simply the energy gradient created by the discovery and development of fossil fuel. Here, suddenly, was all this potential energy-- locked up in the ground-- that could be turned into money if people could be harnessed to that purpose.
The achievements of the media and advertising industry have been absolutely remarkable in convincing us of the absolute necessity of the stupidest things-- all to the purpose of moving electrons in a giant redox scheme that piles up money in the bank by oxidizing all the reduced carbon formed by hundreds of millions of years of plant life on Earth in a just a few decades.
The gradient is decreasing, and themodynamic equilibrium is approaching. Things will work out (though possibly not in a nice way.)
There is also a less insidious reason. Don't forget GIs following WWII: They returned "home" - but they didn't actually go home to the farm. After they'd seen Paree, thousands of people settled in big cities and the newly developing suburbs. It was the "modern" thing to do at the time.
Yes, the herd instinct. Do as the rest are doing.
Although there was no modern Suburbia in WW II Europe.
Alan
Seldom have I laughed so hard at a statement encapsulating such bitter doom, NLNG. Kudos from a fellow physical chemist.
I think you're right here. During the '30s and early '40s the big propaganda for the idea of mass suburbanization came from progressives who wanted to improve the lives of the workers packed into tenements. They, in turn, could be said to be following in the footsteps of that Nazi, Henry Ford, who built Greenfield Village as his reactionary vision of how the working class should live. Both the left and right were wrestling with the bad conditions of cities at that time because it was turning workers into potential revolutionaries. If gas is cheap, and I want to head off a revolution, I want to disperse the disgruntled masses and equip them with cheap V-8s.
What I found interesting in the New Deal propaganda films is that no one thought that urban neighborhoods could be revitalized by rising incomes. Instead, we've gone through one bizarre urban scheme after another, dispersal, high-rise slums, now back to two-floor buildings. Something seems to be missing in our beliefs about cities.
Alan,
The bigotry and fear are primarily class bigotry rather than race bigotry, and I think I've decided the root of most of the craziness in America is television. Because its such a passive media and people can't affect the outcomes of the shows, they carry this attitude into their lives.
Fear and sex are the two main methods of manipulating people, they speak to primal instincts. If a person spend the majority of their free time watching cop shows, they seem more prone to a fearful attitude than people who go outside and take walks in theit neighborhood.. People are taught by advertisers to immitate the actor's on TV, so they want a solution that works in 40 miutes max. The villains are portraed as lower class people, so the ignore the villians who are looting their 401K'S.
Bob Ebersole
I have talked to several older people that "escaped" New Orleans as young adults to the suburbs (white flight). They still have a nostalgia for the old neighborhoods and the relationships there and think of moving back on occasion.
When asked, they will say is was never like that in the Suburbs.
Walking and talking and spending time outside are, I think, the keys. And if we can do this in the heat & humidity of New Orleans, anyone can :-)
But I think race was a major factor.
Alan
Alan,
I am in your fair city today and I am ensconced at Cafe Rose Nicaud on Frenchman Street. A lovely area and one unlike to those I find in the racist suburbs of my backward city Dayton, Ohio. I agree that people wanted to live in a semi farm setting with the amenities of the city but the Johnson administration's civil rights policies did not work for Dayton. It did not heal the rifts from the Civil War or Civil Rights movements. This one size fits all did not work for Dayton, with no geographical barriers to growth. Whites took their money and political power and drove infrastructure growth to the suburbs.
Of course Dayton is observing rapid population decline coupled with an astronomical foreclosure rate at the same time the local planning council is constructing a new sprawl inducing interchange south of the City. Dayton is going to reap the whirlwind, but in the next 5 years you may be able to get a free house in Downtown Dayton as long as you can pay the property Tax.
How long will you be in town ?
Perhaps we could meet. I have not tried Cafe Rose Nicaud.
Best Hopes,
Alan
Alan,
I am in town today (Sun) and then I drive to the Cane River NP to do some work and I will return to NO on Thursday the 23rd and I leave Saturday at 1200. Thursday Night or anytime on Friday the 24th. I would enjoy discussing relationships between our cities connected by electric trolleys and the river. The Great Miami flows through Dayton on the way to the Ohio.
I saw a nice local band at dba on Saturday.
Hope we can connect.
Greg
ghunter@mannus.com
I recommend editing you remark and deleting eMail address. "bots can gather it for spam.
Sent you an eMail.
Alan
Print that offer in Spanish and you'll get more takers than the INS can catch.
"My City Was Gone"
-The Pretenders
I WENT BACK TO OHIO
BUT MY CITY WAS GONE
THERE WAS NO TRAIN STATION
THERE WAS NO DOWNTOWN
SOUTH HOWARD HAD DISAPPEARED
ALL MY FAVORITE PLACES
MY CITY HAD BEEN PULLED DOWN
REDUCED TO PARKING SPACES
A, O, WAY TO GO OHIO
WELL I WENT BACK TO OHIO
BUT MY FAMILY WAS GONE
I STOOD ON THE BACK PORCH
THERE WAS NOBODY HOME
I WAS STUNNED AND AMAZED
MY CHILDHOOD MEMORIES
SLOWLY SWIRLED PAST
LIKE THE WIND THROUGH THE TREES
A, O, OH WAY TO GO OHIO
I WENT BACK TO OHIO
BUT MY PRETTY COUNTRYSIDE
HAD BEEN PAVED DOWN THE MIDDLE
BY A GOVERNMENT THAT HAD NO PRIDE
THE FARMS OF OHIO
HAD BEEN REPLACED BY SHOPPING MALLS
AND MUZAK FILLED THE AIR
FROM SENECA TO CUYAHOGA FALLS
SAID, A, O, OH WAY TO GO OHIO
The Pretenders backed up The Who last fall in Minneapolis and this night they stole the show.
special meaning for me, I grew up in Cuyahoga Falls.
Too bad Limbaugh uses that music on his show.
There have been lots of claims as to why the suburban explosion happened after World War Two. The popular one among city planners is that the Interstate Highway system caused the rapid suburban growth. I think this was more an effect than a cause. In reality I think it was a confluence of many things. Cheap energy, good roads, GI’s returning and wanting their house “in the country,” government policies (FHA, GI bill), herd mentality, and yes racism.
Two racist practices fueled suburban growth: red lining and block busting. In block busting and unscrupulous real estate agent would work to move a black family into a working class white block. Then he would go to all the neighbors and say that “those people” are moving into the neighborhood and you all know what will happen to your property values….. BUT luckily Mr. unscrupulous agent is here to sell your house for you. There are stories of blocks turning over in a couple of weeks from this practice. It was only successful because of racist attitudes of the whites who lived there. The newly formed black neighborhood was then likely red lined. This is a practice by banks where they would not loan money to certain neighborhoods usually based on race. The neighborhood would into decline do to lack of investment further pushing the middle class out to the burbs.
In a funny turn of events, many of those areas in the biggest cities are now being gentrified back into expensive places to live. The boomers who fled these areas can no longer afford to move back. They should have kept the land. Over the long term it would have been a good investment,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blockbusting
"No man who owns his own house and lot can be a Communist. He has too much to do." (Bill Levitt - 1948)
One book that explores that thesis is Behind the Gates: Life, Security and the Pursuit of Happiness in Fortress America by Setha Low.
I'm sure the author's inclusion of San Antonio was no accident...
How will they feel being drafted into a neighborhood militia when the managers go broke and can't pay the security mercenaries? Really old guys and brain-dead teenagers. Might as well draft the staff at McDonald's - our version of Hitler's Volkssturm.
Yes, this gated community nonsense continues. My home (recently sold) was in a suburb engulfed by greater Miami; just a few blocks from US 1 and rapidly gentrifying, it is considered very desireable. Enough well-to-do's moved in to petition the county to wall it off and gate it. I spoke at 3 of 4 public hearings, largly because these are public streets and all the "guards" can do is record tag #s. The next to last hearing I finally understood what this was all about when someone let slip the word "schwartzas" ("blacks" in Yiddish).
Despite my best efforts it went through, they assessed me thousands to put up walls and stupid airconditioned guard houses, and cut off streets so I could no longer walk to the local convenience store.
Hurricane Andrew in 1992 accelerated white flight from Dade County, which is now majority Hispanic. The anglos took their insurance settlements and moved to shiny new suburbs (in drained Everglades) in an adjacent county.
Suburbia is indeed all about racism.
PLAN, PLANt, PLANet
Errol in Miami
That seems blindingly obvious to me. PO is not going to change that. Lets face it, humans are not evolved to be comfortable living close to people that do not look or act like they do. Individuals may be able, but there is zero chance that the future of america will be a multicultural country all packed together in cities like a bunch of mixed nuts.
I think you are making things more complicated than they are.
IMO people chose suburbs simply because they are more convenient to live in. They are also much cheaper and spacious than crowded downtowns.
I have lived in both environments, actually both extremes - from an overcrowded Sofia quarter moving to a typical Atlanta suburb. Cultural shock aside, I find living here much more easier, but, maybe strange to many people this does not mean I like it more. Quite the opposite actually. I think that American culture has evolved to embrace easiness and convenience as the definition of high quality of life, and maybe this is the root of its tragedy.
Amen brother. My PV topped work-from-home burbs house is as much city as I can stand. I used to wait 10 minutes for the elevator to come in my "efficiency" Chicago high rise.
And, half the people/doomers on this site would build armed megabunkers on 40 acres in the name of conservation.
What they hope is that everyone else moves back to the city.
Here's a quick summary. The study looked at two cases. One, a glass and concrete 11-story condo near downtown Toronto. The other, a standard wood-frame, brick facade suburban house in the outer suburbs of Toronto.
The study modeled the embodied energy of the construction materials, the energy used in building operations, and energy used in automobile and transit transportation. The study also modeled the greenhouse gas emissions.
For building materials, low density housing uses 1.5 times the energy as high density housing -- on a per capita basis. But on a square foot basis, the high density condo uses 1.25 times more energy.
The difference can be explained by the fact that dwelling units are smaller in the condo building.
Brick, windows, drywall, and structural concrete are the top four materials in terms of embodied energy.
For building operations, low density housing uses 1.8 times the energy as high density housing on a per capita basis. On a square foot basis, the high density condo uses about the same amount of energy.
For transportation impacts, low density housing uses 3.8 times the energy as high density housing on a per capita basis. On a square foot basis, low density housing uses 2 times times more energy.
When all the energy requirements are totaled up, low density housing uses 2 times the energy as high density housing on a per capita basis. On a square foot basis, low density housing uses about 14% more energy (the researchers round that off and say low and high density housing use about the same amount of energy on a square foot basis).
For greenhouse gas emissions, low density housing emits 2.5 times the GHG as high density housing on a per capita basis. On a square foot basis, low density housing emits 1.5 times times more GHG.
The study concludes:
In addition, it would be useful to model housing types that are more energy efficient than glass and concrete high rises. We need to see energy analyses of rowhouses and low- and midrise multifamily buildings, especially those that use green materials and systems.
Thanks Laurence! I expected the difference would be larger. Double is a lot (and ~4 times for transportation) but I was expecting 10 times or so.
I will keep an eye out for more studies. I would also like to know more about the 3-4 story brick buildings that make up most of the main streets here in the midwest. It is hard to know if they were built because it was efficient to build and heat them, or they are dense and so it is easy to walk.
I wonder if brick construction didn't come about because it is high energy in one central location (the kiln) but very low energy at the widely distributed construction sites. No cranes (for steel) or concrete pumping trucks either.
Jon Freise
Analyze Not Fantasize -D. Meadows
I expected the difference would be larger. Double is a lot (and ~4 times for transportation) but I was expecting 10 times or so
Both buildings were designed in times of cheap energy. And suburban Toronto is not the worst case of Suburbia.
And I think low rises (3-4 stories) are generally more energy efficient that mid-rises (isolated from density issues). It much more cost effective to hyper-insulate an apartment/condo than a SFR (less surface area/sq ft living area and fewer sq ft/person in multi-family).
A number of brick kilns have located next to landfills and use mainly low quality landfill gas for firing. The alternative use is to run diesel generators with landfill gas (lower efficiency than other, large scale means of generating electricity). Thus brick energy value might be adjusted.
Bricks also store quite well, and pr