DrumBeat: September 17, 2007
Posted by Leanan on September 17, 2007 - 9:03am
Topic: Miscellaneous
Oil sets new record ahead of Fed meeting
"If the economy's going to be OK, then oil prices are probably undervalued," said Phil Flynn, an analyst at Alaron Trading Corp. in Chicago.Oil futures rose as high as $80.70 on Monday, a trading record. Oil prices have set several new records over $80 a barrel in recent days for a number of reasons, including perceptions that problems in the subprime mortgage industry would have a minor effect on the economy. The nine-session rally reversed August's downward trend, which was based in part on concerns that the subprime problems would spread, affecting the overall economy and curbing demand for petroleum products.
Don't look to OPEC for oil price relief
But that's not the truly discouraging news from OPEC, which is consuming much higher levels of its own production, leaving less for potential export increases. In something of a vicious circle – or what CIBC World Markets chief economist Jeff Rubin describes as OPEC's "cannibalization" of its own production – record-high oil prices of recent years have sparked an economic boom among Middle East oil producers, as well as Nigeria and Venezuela.
Survive the bear with peak oil bet
Saudi Arabia, the world's biggest oil producer, is the acid test of future supply. The official line is that billions of dollars of capital spending will bring on millions of barrels of additional oil. Peak oil theorists point to petrophysicists' reports that suggest Ghawar, Saudi's biggest field, "is fading as we speak."
Are record oil prices set to torture consumers?
"We're going into this heating oil season the same way we went into the summer driving season -- with supplies well below normal," said Phil Flynn, a senior analyst at Alaron Trading.
Michael J. Economides: The Rise, Fall, and Resurrection of the NOCs
For the better part of 40 years, oil has been the great equalizer, in many ways diminishing the huge imbalance between Europeans, their American cousins, and the rest of the world – the latter on the woefully short end of great cultural and economic events such as the Renaissance, the Industrial Revolution and, certainly, colonialism.In modern times, what separates rich countries from poor is energy consumption. Even more striking is an inverse relationship: most rich countries are poor in oil, and many poor ones are rich in oil and other energy sources.
A Peek at the Peak Oil Problem
"I mean, it doesn't make any sense. We haven't discovered any oil and gas in the Arctic. But if you're modeling and you're trying to look, you can't really say Arizona and Nevada because we've proven there isn't any oil there. So you pick an area we haven't ever been to because therefore there's no way to prove that it's not there."
How Canada Went from 21st to 2nd in World's Oil Reserves
The United States has its hopes pinned on Canada's "tar sands" for North American security in the oil market. But their "black gold" is an environmental nightmare.
Iran’s Aggressive Natural Gas Expansion Plans
As global energy demand rises, natural gas increasingly plays a strategic role. The sector is poised for tremendous growth over the next two decades and some believe that it may overtake oil as the prime fuel between 2020 and 2030. Iran’s huge proven reserves – some 28 trillion cubic meters (about 995 trillion cubic feet) – should make it a key player in the emerging global gas business.
Oh, what a difference 20 months can make. When Lee Raymond retired in early 2006 after leading ExxonMobil to record profits, he was the quintessential Texas oilman. If the notion of developing alternative fuels and putting pressure on Detroit to build more fuel-efficient cars ever crossed his mind, it didn't cross his lips. But as architect of a new study by the National Petroleum Council, a federal advisory group, Raymond has become a sort of Paul Revere of energy, warning of coming shortages by 2030 if America does not act now.
Angola exports to rise to record 1.8 mln bpd
Angola is set to export a record 1.80 million barrels per day of crude oil in November, up 70,000 bpd from its previous record high set in October, traders said on Monday.Crude shipments from OPEC's newest member have set fresh record highs in five of the last six months, according to Reuters data.
UK urged to ban petrol cars by 2040
Britain's third largest political party backed a series of radical proposals Monday to tackle climate change, including a ban on petrol powered cars by 2040.
Utilities Pare Down Lists of Coal-Fired Plants
Since the beginning of 2006, at least two dozen coal-fired plants have been canceled and another three put on hold.
EU to propose splitting energy groups to boost competition
Eager to fire up competition in the energy industry, the European Commission will unveil on Wednesday a sweeping shake-up, which already has many members up in arms over plans to split big power and gas companies.
Zimbabwe: Minister Says Walk to Save Fuel
"The country is facing critical fuel shortages and as government, we encourage all Zimbabweans to reduce the number of cars on the country's roads and walk to save the scarce fuel we have," Nyambuya said.Analysts said Nyambuya's statement was an admission that government was failing to find a lasting solution to the country's fuel problems which started in 1999.
Minnesota Form Nation’s Largest Community Owned Wind Project
The project is also the largest community based energy development (C-BED) project in Minnesota. High Country Energy is expected to qualify for C-BED status, meaning it is owned by Minnesota residents and that 51 percent of the profits are returned to the Minnesota community members over the life of the project.
If we all reduced our driving, shopping, and business by one-seventh, we'd pollute that much less.
Can this really save the planet?
We are constantly told to switch the TV off standby, recycle our plastic bags and boil less water - but does focusing on the small, easy steps distract us from the bigger picture?
The Porridge In Norway Turns Prisoners Green
Norway claims to have the world's first eco-jail. Bastoey prison, which is located on the island of the same name about 50 miles south of Oslo, has solar panels which prisoners helped to install, heats its buildings with wood-waste rather than oil, operates a strict recycling policy and is almost self-sufficient in terms of food.
Sharon Astyk: Can you spare a dime? Why we could....but won't
Klein quotes, among other figures, the observation that it would cost 1.5 *trillion* dollars in five just to get America's basic engineering infrastructure up to speed - just to keep the bridges from falling down, the sewers from backing up. Since that's a bit less than we intend to spend in Iraq, according to Joseph Steigletz, do any of us really believe that our heavily leveraged economy is going to allow us to spend trillions to fix up the existing infrastructure, much less to engage in the vastly more expensive project of adapting that infrastructure to a low energy, renewable dependent future?That's why the gentlemen over at The Oil Drum who reply to every thread with "But all we have to do is...." and then offer some lengthy proposal about electrified rail, 500 new nuclear plants, wind farms everywhere or covering up Arizona with solar panels, so amuse me. And it isn't that I don't think that we'll ever do any of those things. Yes, we will almost certainly build new nuclear plants, wind farms and lay some new rail track. But what we won't be having is a (successful) Manhattan project for renewable energy, or any universal system that allows all of us to spend the next 35 years comfortably adapting our lives to better houses, a renewably powered grid and electrically powered cars.
After Iraq, no one should bank on cheap oil
OIL is the fuel that, by powering the industrial revolution, changed the world. The global economy's need for a secure oil supply is so obvious that former US central bank chief Alan Greenspan has expressed exasperation in his new memoir that "it is politically inconvenient to acknowledge what everyone knows: the Iraq war is largely about oil". He does not mean an outright grab for Iraq's oil. Instead, he writes that Saddam Hussein could have brought "the industrial world to its knees" had he gained control of the Strait of Hormuz and thus of oil shipments out of the Gulf. "I cannot understand why we don't name what is evident and indeed a wholly defensible pre-emptive position," he told The Guardian.
Central Asia: Soaring Bread Prices Give Rise To Domestic Solutions
In an attempt to prevent greater public discontent over the already high food prices, Central Asian governments are struggling to find a solution to the crisis from within their countries.The Uzbek government has put pressure on private businesses not to increase bread prices. The measure has made some vendors close down at the prospect of losing money.
Turkmenistan has even tried to begin growing its own grain. However, the domestic wheat is hugely unpopular with consumers, who complain about its extremely low quality.
Kurt Cobb: Is peak oil a guy thing?
One leader in a peak oil group with whom I spoke recently said that his group found itself split largely along gender lines on one very important issue: How confrontational should the peak oil movement be?
Opec's production capacity to rise 4.68% by 2009
The combined production capacity of the Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries, the group that supplies more than a third of the world's oil, is estimated to rise 4.68 per cent by the end of 2008 to 35.8 million barrels a day from the current 34.2 million bpd, says the latest oil market report of the International Energy Agency (IEA).
Venezuela to boost oil production to five mln bpd by 2012: Chavez
Venezuela will raise its production of crude oil from the current 3.2 million barrels per day (bpd) to 5 million in 2012, in order to maintain a fair price in the market, President Hugo Chavez said during his Sunday television and radio speech.The world is facing an energy crisis since crude oil reserves are being exhausted, the president said.
S-Oil defers new S.Korea refinery decision for 2 yrs
South Korean refiner S-Oil Corp will wait at least a couple of years to reconsider a plan to build a 480,000 barrels per day new refinery because of surging construction costs, its chief said on Monday."In this construction cycle we will not be able to make money," said CEO Samir Tubayyeb in a university lecture. "Construction costs are going up more than three times."
Sabic mining venture cost soars to $5.6bn on construction charge
Saudi Arabian Mining Co (Maaden) said yesterday a phosphate venture it is developing with Saudi Basic Industries Corp (Sabic) will cost 21bn riyals ($5.6bn), 62% more than expected in March.“The increase in the cost of the project ... is due to a rise in prices in the international construction market,” state-owned Maaden said.
Nepal: NOC mulling over POL price hike
The NOC has failed to purchase sufficient amount of petroleum products as the government showed reluctance to adjust the price of POL products at par with the international price, said Ickcha Bikram Thapa, spokesperson at NOC.
More Nations Back U.S. Nuclear Project
A U.S.-initiated project that aims to reduce the dangers of nuclear proliferation and control radioactive waste gained support Sunday, as 11 more nations signed on with original members Russia, China, France and Japan.Under the Global Nuclear Energy Partnership, a limited number of countries including the U.S. and Russia would provide uranium fuel to other nations for powering reactors to generate electricity, and then retrieve the fuel for reprocessing. This would deprive those nations of their own nuclear fuel enrichment programs, which can be used to make atomic arms.
Undermining free public transport
The burning of oil and other fossil fuels is raising the levels of greenhouse gases in our atmosphere and threatening huge climate change. At the same time, peak oil -- the end of the world's cheap oil supplies -- is around the corner. Competition for what's left is fuelling wars. To tackle these major problems facing humanity, new solutions are needed.
Alternative Fuels for Jet Engines
At this year's Paris Air Show, FAA Administrator Marion Blakey described two studies then under way and intended to develop "a national roadmap on the viability of alternative fuels for aviation." Commissioned under the auspices of the FAA's Commercial Aviation Alternative Fuels Initiative (CAAFI) and scheduled for completion this month, the studies address feasibility, costs, technical issues and environmental impact of alternative fuels.
SCOMI Engineering Bhd is expected to ride the hive of activity and investments ploughed into the oil and gas (O&G) sector, but it is the monorail business that is the big and lucrative wild card to its future performance.
Goldman Sachs raises year-end oil price forecast on supply worries
Goldman Sachs has raised its oil price forecast amid near record high prices as the bank reckons demand is likely to exacerbate tight supplies looking ahead.
Dale Allen Pfeiffer: In Case of Martial Law, Break Glass
Many people who follow the news are worried that Bush will declare martial law sometime in the months ahead. If natural crises prove insufficient, they are afraid that he will stage another 9/11. The current economic climate is very similar to the climate at the time of 9/11, though the present brewing economic hurricane will be much worse than the dot.com bust. The economic crises we currently face could very well result in bank closings, the crash of the US dollar, and the impoverishment of a large segment of the US population. What is more, with peak oil and the dawn of a new era of energy depletion it is unlikely that we will be able resuscitate our economy once the collapse is complete.
In his latest couple of videos, the dyed one mentioned Western civilization's contribution to global warming among his list of complaints of quite what was wrong with the state of affairs, which he suggested a bout of Osamanomics could cure. The generation of largely American (which is not a comment on their girth) economists brought up on the ideas of Reaganomics who now rule the roost across the global financial system can perhaps imagine the very opposite of what they believe in, namely a demand-led reduction of Group of Seven (G7) economies that culminates in collapsing economic growth across Asia, thereby keeping billions of people mired in poverty.
Iran impatient with India over gas pipeline
Iran expressed impatience with India over the finalising of a multi-billion dollar gas pipeline deal via Pakistan, warning that it could go ahead with Pakistan alone if India procrastinated.
Mammoth dung, prehistoric goo may speed warming
For millennia, layers of animal waste and other organic matter left behind by the creatures that used to roam the Arctic tundra have been sealed inside the frozen permafrost. Now climate change is thawing the permafrost and lifting this prehistoric ooze from suspended animation.But Zimov, a scientist who for almost 30 years has studied climate change in Russia's Arctic, believes that as this organic matter becomes exposed to the air it will accelerate global warming faster than even some of the most pessimistic forecasts.
Climate talks in Montreal to take dual aim
Representatives of 190 countries will meet in Montreal Monday for talks on the twin goals of combating global warming and restoring the ozone layer.
Greenspan clarifies Iraq war, oil link
Clarifying a controversial comment in his new memoir, former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan said he told the White House before the Iraq war that removing Saddam Hussein was “essential” to secure world oil supplies, according to an interview published on Monday.
West's ravenous oil appetite may lead to tough sacrifices
One of the backdrops to the meeting was a landmark report by the U.S. National Petroleum Council entitled Hard Truths About Global Energy. The study projects global energy demand will grow by at least 50 per cent by 2030. Essentially all that growth will come from the developing world. Given that energy use is currently balanced between developed and developing countries, this means a doubling of energy use by developing countries in 23 years. Delegates from Europe, Latin America and China expressed no disagreement with the conclusions of the report.
Petroleos de Venezuela to Convert Accounts Away From Dollars
Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez instructed Petroleos de Venezuela SA, the state oil company, to convert its investment accounts from dollars to euros and Asian currencies to reduce risk.The decision may help weaken the dollar as the Federal Reserve prepares to lower interest rates this week, said Philip Wee, an economist at DBS Bank Ltd. in Singapore. The currency has fallen against 14 of the 16 most-active over the past year, partly as governments signaled they may diversify their holdings away from the U.S., the world's primary destination for reserves.
Opec's Decision is a Compromise amid Unclear Economic Conditions
The OPEC decision, based on the statement by Secretary General Abdullah al-Badri during a news conference after the meeting, represents a message to consumers that when it took the decision, the ministerial council took their point of view into consideration. This is the first increase in production in two years; industrial countries have requested such a move for a while, in order to rein in the continuing increase in the price of oil since 2004, when it reached record levels ($78.77 for Brent).
Since 2005, Devon has reported $390,000 in stolen items and products from fields in the Barnett Shale. Almost $150,000 of that total has occurred since January 2007.Some of the more common items stolen from the fields include flow meters, copper wire, solar panels, gates and fence panels, tubing, pipe, tools, chemical and oil pumps, trailers, large drill bits, meter runs and even oil condensate.
Iraq to boost oil output to 6m bpd in 10 yrs
The Iraqi Minister of Oil announced that Iraq is seeking to increase its oil production by 3.5 million barrels per day (bpd) by the end of 2009, increasing to 6 million bpd within the next decade, IDP reported.
Qatar constructs chlorine plant for oil producing purposes
Qatar Chlorine, a private shareholding company, will construct a world-class plant in the Mesaieed Industrial City for commercial production of hydrochloric acid and byproducts, a company spokesman said....Hydrochloric acid is an important chemical used in the oil and gas industry for "acidizing" wells to improve the flow rate and enhance the production capacity.
Thinking about my presentation got me musing about the difficulty of imagining a future that's neither identical to the present, nor on the verge of apocalypse. Not a utopia, per se, but a future that gives us a bit more to hope for than to fear.
Gates rejects Greenspan claim war is about oil
U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates on Sunday rejected former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan's statement that the Iraq war "is largely about oil."
Alaska integrity office investigates BP practices on Slope
Gov. Sarah Palin and state Resources Commissioner Tom Irwin have ordered the state's new Petroleum Systems Integrity Office to conduct a special investigation of a series of small fires in BP Exploration (Alaska) Inc.'s North Slope production facilities, the governor and Irwin announced in a Sept. 11 press conference.
Iran says Crescent should pay more for gas
Iran will find other customers for gas assigned to a deal being negotiated with Crescent Petroleum or use the fuel itself if the UAE firm does not agree to pay a higher price, Iran's oil minister said on Sunday.
Pemex to Resume Natural Gas Service a Week After Mexico Blasts
Petroleos Mexicanos, the state oil monopoly, will "gradually" resume natural gas service tomorrow, a week after guerrilla attacks on pipelines cut fuel supply to thousands of businesses across central Mexico.
Mexican Explosions and Their After Effects
A series of explosions in Mexico, on September 9th and September 10th, has raised pertinent questions about Mexican safety and security that still have not been answered.
Many people have been saying that the invasion (and occupation) of Iraq is about oil. I believe that there is more than oil involved, but certainly oil was a driving motivator.
Coal and nuclear options ‘must be looked at’
WESTERN countries face a politically and economically difficult future as governments are faced with finding alternatives to oil, according to a former US Secretary of Energy.Nuclear energy and restarting coal mining are some of the realities that political parties will have to consider selling to voters, said Dr James Schlesinger.
Myanmar to auction gems, jewellery in November
Myanmar will auction off more precious gems and jewellery in November in the fifth such sale this year aimed at bringing foreign currency into the isolated nation, state media reported Sunday....A hike in fuel prices on August 15 left many people unable to afford even the trip to work, sparking rare demonstrations across the country.
A wealth of oil, gas and other natural resources, however, has lined the junta's coffers, with India, China and Thailand jostling to exploit their neighbor's natural wealth to fuel their growing economies.
Inflationary spiral could spell an end to era of cheap food
Parisians are bemoaning the price of a baguette, Italians have organised a pasta boycott and the Mexican public have held street protests about the cost of tortillas. Rocketing food prices are infuriating consumers and pressurising politicians worldwide. But is this a temporary blip, or has the era of cheap food come to an end?



People that say the Iraq war wasn't about oil are like people that go to strip joints "for the food".
Hear that George Will?
I did inhale.
Gotta love those spicy Iraqi chicken wings...
--
All these memories will be lost in time
like tears in rain
Good Morning, Leanan
Excellent compilation of articles.
From Ray McGovern-a Dirty Hippy. Right from the beginning.
http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article18406.htm
But a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit forced the Commerce Department to turn over task force documents, including a map of Iraqi oilfields, pipelines, refineries, terminals, and potential areas for exploration; a Pentagon chart “Foreign Suitors for Iraqi Oilfield Contracts;” and another chart detailing Iraqi oil and gas projects—all dated March 2001.
On the 60 Minutes, program on December 15, 2002, Steve Croft asked then-defense secretary Donald Rumsfeld, “What do you say to people who think this [the coming invasion of Iraq] is about oil?” Rumsfeld replied:
“Nonsense. It just isn’t. There—there—there are certain............. things like that, myths that are floating around. I’m glad you asked. I—it has nothing to do with oil, literally nothing to do with oil.”
Arkansaw of Samuel L Clemens
Re: Inflationary spiral could spell an end to era of cheap food
So it begins. This is just a taste of the future as Peak Oil induces an ever upward oil price spiral. The market's natural response to shortage, which is, to "ration by price". We've already experienced the spiral twice, after the OPEC Oil Embargo and after the Iranian Crisis. But, those were short term events and we muddled thru (unless you were a farmer who lost his farm or a worker who lost his career). We all gotta eat and the die back from demand destruction will be the result of business as usual when TSHTF. The only hope to minimize the damage is rationing and there's little hope we will see that in time, given the politics of the matter.
E. Swanson
What I find interesting is that people complain about the price of staples, like bread and pasta. But I suspect the greatest shock is yet to come - increases in the price of meat which I suppose would lead to more and more meals with no meat involved. Or perhaps reductions in the portion sizes, which our society could really use.
I tried to interest my girlfriend in a vegetarian restaurant that is nearby - I have tried it a couple of times on my own, and the things I have tried so far seem pretty good. Unfortunately she is a meat-and-potatoes kind of girl. The first time I brought it up, she suggested some other place where she could get ribs.
According to WorldWatch:
"The raising of animals for food is behind virtually every major category of environmental damage now threatening the future of humans - deforestation, erosion, fresh water scarcity, air and water pollution, climate change, biodiversity loss, social injustice, the destabilization of communities, and the spread of disease.”
They go on to say in this report that raising animals for food creates more
greenhouse gases than ALL OF THE CARS AND TRUCKS IN THE WORLD COMBINED.
The price of meat cannot go up fast enough, imho. It is perhaps more subsidized than even the automobile.
http://www.worldwatch.org/node/819
you might want to correct your statement.
it's not just raising animals for food, it's the modern industrialized version of doing it thats the problem.
You may want to clarify what it is you mean, and provide an actual argument.
I have never seen any evidence that livestock production anywhere near current scale could done in a way that improves on the status quo or is sustainable.
I deplore modern factory farming, but don't think there is any way to improve efficiencies in a non-industrial farming context. While it would be much better for the animals, it would likely be even more resource intensive.
Reducing the impact of livestock production on the climate can not be done without reducing the quantity of livestock raised and consumed.
Meat eating above a certain level is consumerism, just like using more oil than needed is.
I find it hypocritical that so many who point fingers blaming others for non-sustainable use of fuel so adamantly deny that they are equally complict with their non-sustainable consumption of meat.
You are right, there is no sensible way for most people to have meat with every meal after cheap fossil fuel.
Meat does however have a place in this world. On a small farm, an animal can inconspicuously graze grass or eat leftover human foods, and its meat is by far the most protein and nutrient dense, easily preservable food available to the small farmer.
Before agriculture, the same was true of herd animals who were hunted for their meat, skin and bones.
Chickens produce eggs and they'll eat whatever bugs don't have the sense to stay out of their way. Anything green and growing is fair game, too, so you've got to keep them out of the garden. Eggs and beans are going to be two key protein sources post peak.
The industrial farms won't survive and it'll go back to how it was when I was a kid. We'd get two hundred chicks at the beginning of spring. The males were promptly processed once they were large enough and a hundred surviving females hung out with one very busy rooster producing lots and lots of eggs. We sold a couple of dozen eggs a day at $0.50 a dozen after we'd eaten our fill. Their droppings were periodically spread on the neighbor's field, but I imagine those end up in my expanded garden going forward.
If the rest of the world can refrain from flying to bits I think things are going to be just fine here in the land that time forgot ...
"I think things are going to be just fine here in the land that time forgot ..."
Which is where? Just curious :)
"God is just an invisible friend for adults. Just-in-time techno fixes are their security blankets."
Another thing you won't see on an industrial farm....
http://bbsnews.net/article.php/20070916110536662
Cannabidiol May be Effective in Preventing Bovine Spongiforme Enzephalopathy (Mad Cow Disease)
It's worked for me.
I agree. I don't have any issue with meat consumption as such. I do have problems with the conditions animals are subjected to as well as the detruction of the environmnet and waste of energy that comes from meat heavy, processed foods.
I just don't think it is fair to cast cars as a great evil and give the microwave dinner a free pass. I think diminishing energy resources will change the way we eat as much as the way we move around.
We are going to have to get used to not being able to hop in the SUV everytime we want to go anywhere and not being able to pop into McDonald's when we want a bite to eat.
Actually, I see this as fairly optimistic. The massive waste implicit in our current lifestyles means that there is a lot of low hanging fruit on the consumption side of the equation.
I do wish we were better planners, but expect that the only way these changes will take place is when the energy-intensive activities become expensive.
Blackwater security firm has been kicked out of Iraq following a Sunday incident.
Then the State Dept and other US Diplomats go as well
because Blackwater does their security.
If Blackwater goes, the US goes.
Arkansaw of Samuel L Clemens
Blackwater will have lots of work to do in North America in the year or two.
Doing what, armed robbery?
Another link to it, I was about to post the story:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6998788.stm
| The problem will solve itself.
| But not in a nice way.
DIYer is right - they're stung badly by this, assuming they don't manage to get it reversed or diffuse the people away to different operations. How do we get Congress to dismantle it while in transit so it doesn't reappear here?
We are the militia and the private army of some religious fanatic is not welcome in our lands.
I *HATE* Blackwater after some run-ins here in New Orleans post-Katrina !
Mercenaries ought not be used, especially on US soil !
Alan
Blackwater was used because the New Orleans police fled. They were there faster than FEMA. The worst things one can say about Blackwater in NO have been the case for decades with regular police forces in cities such as LA. At least Blackwater was well equipped. While I'm not defending either Blackwater or the use of Blackwater domestically, we shouldn't make the non-story of Blackwater after Katrina to be something it wasn't.
Discussion of this topic inevitably leads to someone invoking Halliburton/Blackwater concentration camps. This country didn't have any trouble setting up such facilities in the aftermath of Pearl Harbor. Without the help of either organization.
Blackwater was NOT "in there first". They came in later as an Occupation force and a despicable one at that. And about 80% of NOPD stayed at their posts (as did NOFD).
The Coast Guard were the shining heroes in the week following Katrina. Both the local unit and reinforcements from outside. they flew first, longer and harder than any other group of helos. It is a shame that Bush gave them no Unit Commendation Medals or individual honors.
Alan
I just think the real reason people don't like Blackwater is because they were started by Eric Prince (aka "right-wing fundamentalist Christian from a powerful Michigan Republican family") and his ties to the Bushes. Not because of anything in particular that they have done. There are hundreds of private security firms in Iraq. All kinds of organizations contract to the US government.
The real reason people don't like Blackwater (or any mercenary outfit for that matter) is they nothing more than goons with guns for hire.
Right. But this is not either surprising or alarming. Some people don't like guns or goons. Some people don't like the police. Kent State? Rodney King? Hell's Angels at Altamont?
Again - just posted this link, but it's relevant here - I think THIS is the reason people don't like Blackwater:
http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2007/6/16/113727/006
It isn't just who Prince is, it's what his vision is too. Don't forget this guy was behind one of the largest non military build up of arms during the Clinton years to fight against the government if they didn't toe some unspecified right wing line.
--
All these memories will be lost in time
like tears in rain
The Coasties are the real heroes all over the country. I just wish they weren't subsumed into Homeland Security. They have been shoehorned everywhere-the Dept of Commerce, or an agency in the Dept of Transportation. And shine wherever, at least to now, in service to the country. They are the oldest service in the country.
A recent Hollywood movie the Guardian, even if you don't care for Kevin Cosner, is worth seeing. They continually risk life and limb in the worst conditions for anyone, not just in movies.
I never got why this movie was panned. It was no cornier than any star-vehicle action movie.
I actually though it was great, and a good relection on the Coast Guard. I recommend watching it.
--
All these memories will be lost in time
like tears in rain
"The scale of operations during the Katrina response defies imagination and the statistics generated are almost unbelievable. Search and rescue operations alone saved 24,135 lives from imminent danger, usually off the roofs of the victims’ homes as flood waters lapped at their feet. Coast Guardsmen “evacuated to safety” 9,409 patients from local hospitals. In total, 33,545 souls owed their lives to the men and women of the nation’s oldest continuous-going sea service, nearly equaling the number of persons the Coast Guard saves during a calendar year."
http://www.uscg.mil/hq/g-cp/history/katrina/karthistory.asp
http://www.uscg.mil/hq/g-cp/history/katrina/katrinaindex.asp
Sure, the gummint didn't need Halliburton back in those days because the administration wasn't filled with hapless incompetents and cronies.
And I don't think there was any need to have heavily armed mercenaries roaming the streets of NOLA. The people needed help and supplies, not intimidation. I can certainly understand Alan's (and other residents') dim view of Blackwater after that. But remember that Blackwater was there on contract - politicians made the decision to put them there.
Discussion of this topic inevitably leads to someone invoking Halliburton/Blackwater concentration camps. This country didn't have any trouble setting up such facilities in the aftermath of Pearl Harbor.
Via: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_9066
Letter of Apology makes it sound like you are pimp'n for a bad idea.
I think THIS is the end game here for Private Military Contractors (to pimp an essay of mine on the topic):
http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2007/6/16/113727/006
--
All these memories will be lost in time
like tears in rain
Interesting essay, btw.
"You can never solve a problem on the level on which it was created."
Albert Einstein